24/7 Space News
IRON AND ICE
New analysis upends belief that asteroid Vesta has planetary interior
illustration only
New analysis upends belief that asteroid Vesta has planetary interior
by Bethany Mauger
East Lansing MI (SPX) Apr 30, 2025

For decades, scientists believed Vesta, one of the largest objects in our solar system's asteroid belt, wasn't just an asteroid. They concluded that Vesta has a crust, mantle and core - fundamental properties of a planet.

Astronomers studied it for clues to how early planets grew, and what Earth might have looked like in its infancy.

Now, Michigan State University has contributed to research that flips this notion on its head.

A team led by the NASA Jet Propulsion Lab or JPL published a paper in Nature Astronomy revealing Vesta's interior structure is more uniform than previously thought. These findings startled researchers who, until then, assumed Vesta was a protoplanet that never grew to a full planet.

"The lack of a core was very surprising," said MSU Earth and Environmental Sciences Assistant Professor Seth Jacobson, a co-author on the paper. "It's a really different way of thinking about Vesta."

What is Vesta's true identity? The research team has two hypotheses that need further exploration.

The first possibility is Vesta went through incomplete differentiation, meaning it started the melting process needed to give the asteroid distinct layers, like a core, mantle and crust, but never finished. The second is a theory Jacobson floated at an astronomy conference years ago -- Vesta is a broken chunk off a growing planet in our solar system.

At the conference, Jacobson wanted other researchers to consider the possibility that some meteorites could be debris from collisions that took place during the planet formation era. He included Vesta in his suggestion but hadn't considered it a real possibility.

"This idea went from a somewhat silly suggestion to a hypothesis that we're now taking seriously due to this re-analysis of NASA Dawn mission data," Jacobson said.

More than an asteroid

Most asteroids are made of a very ancient chondritic material, appearing like a cosmic sedimentary gravel. In contrast, Vesta's surface is covered in volcanic basaltic rocks. Those rocks indicated to scientists that Vesta went through a melting process called planetary differentiation, where the metal sinks to the center and forms a core.

NASA launched the Dawn spacecraft in 2007 to study Vesta and Ceres, the two largest objects in the asteroid belt. The goal was to better understand how planets were formed.

Dawn spent months from 2011 to 2012 orbiting Vesta, measuring its gravity field and taking high-resolution images to create a very detailed map of its surface. After performing similar tasks at Ceres, the mission finished in 2018, and scientists published findings from the data.

Jacobson said the more that researchers used the data, the better they got at processing it. They found ways to more accurately calibrate measurements that yield an improved picture of Vesta's makeup. That's why Ryan Park, a JPL senior research scientist and principal engineer, and his team decided to reprocess Vesta's measurements.

"For years, conflicting gravity data from Dawn's observations of Vesta created puzzles," Park said. "After nearly a decade of refining our calibration and processing techniques, we achieved remarkable alignment between Dawn's Deep Space Network radiometric data and onboard imaging data. We were thrilled to confirm the data's strength in revealing Vesta's deep interior. Our findings show Vesta's history is far more complex than previously believed, shaped by unique processes like interrupted planetary differentation and late-stage collisions."

Planetary scientists can estimate the size of a celestial body's core by measuring what's called the moment of inertia. It's a concept from physics that describes how difficult it is to change the rotation of an object around an axis. Jacobson compared this concept to a figure skater spinning on ice. They change their speed by pulling their arms in to speed up and moving them outward to slow down. Their moment of inertia is changed by the changing position of their arms.

Similarly, an object in space with a larger core is like a ballerina with their arms pulled in. Celestial bodies with a dense core move differently than one with no core at all. Armed with this knowledge, the research team measured the rotation and gravity field of Vesta. The results showed Vesta didn't behave like an object with a core, challenging prior ideas about how it formed.

Two hypotheses

Neither hypothesis has been explored enough to rule either out, but both have problems that require more research to explain. While incomplete differentiation is possible, it doesn't line up with the meteorites researchers have collected over time.

"We're really confident these meteorites came from Vesta," Jacobson said. "And these don't show obvious evidence of incomplete differentiation."

The alternative explanation is based on the idea that as the terrestrial planets formed, large collisions occurred, mostly growing the planets but also generating impact debris. The ejected materials from those collisions would include rocks resulting from melting, and, like Vesta, they wouldn't have a core.

Jacobson's lab was already exploring the consequences of giant impacts during the planet formation era. He's working with one of his graduate students, Emily Elizondo, on the idea that some asteroids in the asteroid belt are pieces ejected from the growing planets.

This idea is still far from proven. More models need to be created and fine-tuned to prove that Vesta is an ancient chunk of a forming planet. Scientists can adjust how they study Vesta meteorites to dive deeper into either hypothesis, Jacobson said. They could also do further studies with the new approaches to the Dawn mission data.

This paper is only the beginning of a new direction of study, Jacobson said. It could forever change how scientists look at differentiated worlds.

"No longer is the Vesta meteorite collection a sample of a body in space that failed to make it as a planet," Jacobson said. "These could be pieces of an ancient planet before it grew to full completion. We just don't know which planet that is yet."

Research Report:A small core in Vesta inferred from Dawn's observations

Related Links
Michigan State University
Asteroid and Comet Mission News, Science and Technology

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
IRON AND ICE
NASA's Lucy Spacecraft Images Asteroid Donaldjohanson
San Antonio TX (SPX) Apr 23, 2025
In its second asteroid encounter, NASA's Lucy spacecraft obtained a close look at a uniquely shaped fragment of an asteroid that formed about 150 million years ago. The spacecraft has begun returning images that were collected as it flew approximately 600 miles (960 km) from the asteroid Donaldjohanson on April 20, 2025. The asteroid was previously observed to have large brightness variations over a 10-day period, so some of Lucy team members' expectations were confirmed when the first images show ... read more

IRON AND ICE
ELVIS imaging tech heads to space to advance life detection

ISRO embarks on Ax-4 mission to advance deep space science and sustainability

NASA Notes Key Milestone in Blue Origin's Orbital Reef Development

Aerospacelab chosen to supply satellite platform for JAXA mission via Mitsui Bussan Aerospace

IRON AND ICE
Slingshot launches turnkey system to enable space domain awareness for all nations

Firefly to Develop Lighter Rocket Nozzle Extension Under AFRL Contract

Rocket Lab to Conduct Hypersonic Test Flight Under MACH-TB 2.0 Program

Space Systems Command bolsters satellite processing for future launches

IRON AND ICE
China opens international payload opportunities for Mars sample return mission

Crystal record reveals ancient wet phases on Mars

Searching for the Dark in the Light

NASA's Curiosity Rover May Have Solved Mars' Missing Carbonate Mystery

IRON AND ICE
Space is a place to found a community not a colony

China's Shenzhou-19 astronauts return to Earth

SAR astronauts prepare for landmark 2026 space mission

China unveils new round of space station life science experiments

IRON AND ICE
Myriota adds 16 satellites through expanded Spire Global agreement to boost IoT network

Apex secures 200 million to ramp up satellite bus production

Carbice thermal tech to enhance heat control on SWISSto12 HummingSat satellites

Amazon launches first Starlink-rival internet satellites

IRON AND ICE
China pioneers daytime satellite laser ranging in Earth moon space

Microsoft reports strong results driven by cloud and AI; Urges fast 'resolution' of transatlantic trade issues

NASA develops flight-ready aerogel antennas for next-gen airspace communications

British Steel abandons job cut plans after govt rescue

IRON AND ICE
Super Earths Found Abundant in Distant Orbits Across the Galaxy

Astronomers detect exoplanet on rare perpendicular path around binary brown dwarfs

Where are all the aliens?: Fermi's Paradox explained

The eukaryotic leap as a shift in life's genetic algorithm

IRON AND ICE
Juno reveals subsurface secrets of Jupiter and Io

Planetary Alignment Provides NASA Rare Opportunity to Study Uranus

On Jupiter, it's mushballs all the way down

20 years of Hubble data reveals evolving weather patterns on Uranus

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.