24/7 Space News
CARBON WORLDS
Weaker ocean circulation could enhance CO2 buildup in the atmosphere
illustration only
Weaker ocean circulation could enhance CO2 buildup in the atmosphere
by Jennifer Chu | MIT News
Boston MA (SPX) Jul 09, 2024

As climate change advances, the ocean's overturning circulation is predicted to weaken substantially. With such a slowdown, scientists estimate the ocean will pull down less carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. However, a slower circulation should also dredge up less carbon from the deep ocean that would otherwise be released back into the atmosphere. On balance, the ocean should maintain its role in reducing carbon emissions from the atmosphere, if at a slower pace.

However, a new study by an MIT researcher finds that scientists may have to rethink the relationship between the ocean's circulation and its long-term capacity to store carbon. As the ocean gets weaker, it could release more carbon from the deep ocean into the atmosphere instead.

The reason has to do with a previously uncharacterized feedback between the ocean's available iron, upwelling carbon and nutrients, surface microorganisms, and a little-known class of molecules known generally as "ligands." When the ocean circulates more slowly, all these players interact in a self-perpetuating cycle that ultimately increases the amount of carbon that the ocean outgases back to the atmosphere.

"By isolating the impact of this feedback, we see a fundamentally different relationship between ocean circulation and atmospheric carbon levels, with implications for the climate," says study author Jonathan Lauderdale, a research scientist in MIT's Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences. "What we thought is going on in the ocean is completely overturned."

Lauderdale says the findings show that "we can't count on the ocean to store carbon in the deep ocean in response to future changes in circulation. We must be proactive in cutting emissions now, rather than relying on these natural processes to buy us time to mitigate climate change."

Box flow
In 2020, Lauderdale led a study that explored ocean nutrients, marine organisms, and iron, and how their interactions influence the growth of phytoplankton around the world. Phytoplankton are microscopic, plant-like organisms that live on the ocean surface and consume a diet of carbon and nutrients that upwell from the deep ocean and iron that drifts in from desert dust.

The more phytoplankton that can grow, the more carbon dioxide they can absorb from the atmosphere via photosynthesis, and this plays a large role in the ocean's ability to sequester carbon.

For the 2020 study, the team developed a simple "box" model, representing conditions in different parts of the ocean as general boxes, each with a different balance of nutrients, iron, and ligands - organic molecules that are thought to be byproducts of phytoplankton. The team modeled a general flow between the boxes to represent the ocean's larger circulation - the way seawater sinks, then is buoyed back up to the surface in different parts of the world.

This modeling revealed that, even if scientists were to "seed" the oceans with extra iron, that iron wouldn't have much of an effect on global phytoplankton growth. The reason was due to a limit set by ligands. It turns out that, if left on its own, iron is insoluble in the ocean and therefore unavailable to phytoplankton. Iron only becomes soluble at "useful" levels when linked with ligands, which keep iron in a form that plankton can consume. Lauderdale found that adding iron to one ocean region to consume additional nutrients robs other regions of nutrients that phytoplankton there need to grow. This lowers the production of ligands and the supply of iron back to the original ocean region, limiting the amount of extra carbon that would be taken up from the atmosphere.

Unexpected switch
Once the team published their study, Lauderdale worked the box model into a form that he could make publicly accessible, including ocean and atmosphere carbon exchange and extending the boxes to represent more diverse environments, such as conditions similar to the Pacific, the North Atlantic, and the Southern Ocean. In the process, he tested other interactions within the model, including the effect of varying ocean circulation.

He ran the model with different circulation strengths, expecting to see less atmospheric carbon dioxide with weaker ocean overturning - a relationship that previous studies have supported, dating back to the 1980s. But what he found instead was a clear and opposite trend: The weaker the ocean's circulation, the more CO2 built up in the atmosphere.

"I thought there was some mistake," Lauderdale recalls. "Why were atmospheric carbon levels trending the wrong way?"

When he checked the model, he found that the parameter describing ocean ligands had been left "on" as a variable. In other words, the model was calculating ligand concentrations as changing from one ocean region to another.

On a hunch, Lauderdale turned this parameter "off," which set ligand concentrations as constant in every modeled ocean environment, an assumption that many ocean models typically make. That one change reversed the trend, back to the assumed relationship: A weaker circulation led to reduced atmospheric carbon dioxide. But which trend was closer to the truth?

Lauderdale looked to the scant available data on ocean ligands to see whether their concentrations were more constant or variable in the actual ocean. He found confirmation in GEOTRACES, an international study that coordinates measurements of trace elements and isotopes across the world's oceans, that scientists can use to compare concentrations from region to region. Indeed, the molecules' concentrations varied. If ligand concentrations do change from one region to another, then his surprise new result was likely representative of the real ocean: A weaker circulation leads to more carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

"It's this one weird trick that changed everything," Lauderdale says. "The ligand switch has revealed this completely different relationship between ocean circulation and atmospheric CO2 that we thought we understood pretty well."

Slow cycle
To see what might explain the overturned trend, Lauderdale analyzed biological activity and carbon, nutrient, iron, and ligand concentrations from the ocean model under different circulation strengths, comparing scenarios where ligands were variable or constant across the various boxes.

This revealed a new feedback: The weaker the ocean's circulation, the less carbon and nutrients the ocean pulls up from the deep. Any phytoplankton at the surface would then have fewer resources to grow and would produce fewer byproducts (including ligands) as a result. With fewer ligands available, less iron at the surface would be usable, further reducing the phytoplankton population. There would then be fewer phytoplankton available to absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and consume upwelled carbon from the deep ocean.

"My work shows that we need to look more carefully at how ocean biology can affect the climate," Lauderdale points out. "Some climate models predict a 30 percent slowdown in the ocean circulation due to melting ice sheets, particularly around Antarctica. This huge slowdown in overturning circulation could actually be a big problem: In addition to a host of other climate issues, not only would the ocean take up less anthropogenic CO2 from the atmosphere, but that could be amplified by a net outgassing of deep ocean carbon, leading to an unanticipated increase in atmospheric CO2 and unexpected further climate warming."

Research Report:"Ocean iron cycle feedbacks decouple atmospheric CO2 from meridional overturning circulation changes"

Related Links
Department of Earth, Atmospheric, and Planetary Sciences
Carbon Worlds - where graphite, diamond, amorphous, fullerenes meet

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters
Tweet

RELATED CONTENT
The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
CARBON WORLDS
Plants Store Less Carbon than Previously Estimated, Study Shows
London, UK (SPX) Jun 25, 2024
The carbon stored globally by plants is shorter-lived and more vulnerable to climate change than previously thought, according to a new study. The findings have implications for our understanding of the role of nature in mitigating climate change, including the potential for nature-based carbon removal projects such as mass tree-planting. The research, carried out by an international team led by Dr. Heather Graven at Imperial College London and published today in Science, reveals that existi ... read more

CARBON WORLDS
MIT scientists develop way to toughen up 'good' bacteria, extend shelf life

Space Renaissance International Achieves Observer Status At U.N. COPUOS

NASA Seeks Feedback on Requirements for New Commercial Space Stations

HERA crew complete 45-day simulated journey to Mars

CARBON WORLDS
SpaceX completes Starlink launch, brings Direct to Cell satellite total to 103

Firefly Aerospace Successfully Launches Eight CubeSat Satellites

Starliner undergoing thruster testing before indefinite return flight

Space Pioneer Issues Apology After Engine Test Explosion

CARBON WORLDS
Volunteer Crew to Exit NASA's Simulated Mars Habitat After 378 Days

This desert moss has the potential to grow on Mars

Crew inside NASA's Mars habitat simulator to exit after more than a year

NASA Parachute Sensor Testing Could Make EPIC Mars Landings

CARBON WORLDS
Chinese Scientists Develop Novel Rosa Roxburghii Varieties via Space Breeding

Shenzhou 18 Crew to Conduct Second Extravehicular Activities

Hainan Launch Center Completes Construction for First Mission

Ten make the cut for China's fourth batch of astronauts

CARBON WORLDS
NASA Shares Use Requirements With Commercial Destination Partners

Dhruva Space partners with Kinis to provide space-based IoT connectivity in India

Indonesia aims to build cutting-edge spaceport but faces obstacles

Leaf Space enables Sateliot to scale without significant capex in the ground segment

CARBON WORLDS
Quadrupolar Nuclei Measured Using Zero-Field NMR for the First Time

Researchers Uncover New Insights into High-Temperature Superconductivity in Copper Oxides

Serbia top court opens way for disputed lithium mining project

Amazon to build 'top secret' cloud for Australia's spies

CARBON WORLDS
New Method to Enhance Microbe Viability for Space and Extreme Environments

MIT engineers find a way to protect microbes from extreme conditions

Scientists reveal the density differences of sub-Neptunes due to resonance

Organic material from Mars reveals the likely origin of life's building blocks

CARBON WORLDS
NASA's Juno Observes Lava Lakes on Jupiter's Moon Io

Understanding Cyclones on Jupiter Through Oceanography

Unusual Ion May Influence Uranus and Neptune's Magnetic Fields

NASA's Europa Clipper Arrives in Florida for Launch Preparation

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2024 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.