. 24/7 Space News .
Israeli General Quits Over War Management

Former Director of Military Intelligence, retired Maj. Gen. Uri Saguy, told the conference the army "was not prepared" for the operation it carried out. The troops were used in a way that "did not contribute (to achieving) the goals," he said. photo courtesy AFP
by Joshua Brilliant
UPI Israel Correspondent
Herzliya, Israel (UPI) Sep 13, 2006
The head of the army's Northern Command resigned Wednesday becoming the first -- and probably not the only -- senior officer to quit in light of the army's failures during the war with Hezbollah.

A military statement said that Maj. Gen. Udi Adam "asked to resign his position in the near future. The chief of staff has accepted (the)... request."

Adam has been responsible for the Lebanese and Syrian fronts. It is under his watch that Hezbollah kidnapped two soldiers in the attack that led to the month-long war. Thousands of soldiers backed by artillery, tanks, and helicopter gunships eventually fought in southern Lebanon but failed to stop the 4,000 Hezbollah rocket attacks that rained upon Israel at a rate of some 100 to 200 a day.

Soldiers complained they lacked equipment and reservists sometimes bought gear in private stores. They have not trained for months, they were sent on missions from which they recalled in midway, some missions were unnecessary and they did not get supplies.

Some analysts argued the war nevertheless enhanced Israel's deterrent capability. Israel devastated Hezbollah areas in Beirut, villages, and according to Lebanese accounts killed more than 1,000 people.

Retired intelligence Maj. Gen. Yaakov Amidror told diplomats the damage Israel inflicted on Hezbollah was so severe it would take that organization two years to regain the capability it lost. The fighting, "Made everyone around us ...understand that there are some red lines that if (they) will be crossed, by the Syrians, or the Palestinians or the Lebanese, the retaliation ...will be unproportional," he said.

However participants at a conference the International Policy Institute for Counter Terrorism is holding this week in Herzliya, north of Tel Aviv, indicated otherwise.

Former Foreign Minister Silvan Shalom said the war's outcome is, "Very problematic in terms of how the Arab world views us, the United States sees us, and ...the way we see ourselves."

Reserve intelligence Brig. Gen. Shalom Harari said the outcome shattered Palestinian belief that Israel is unbeatable. Hezbollah's leader Hassan Nasrallah became a hero with songs in his honor.

Former Director of Military Intelligence, retired Maj. Gen. Uri Saguy, told the conference the army "was not prepared" for the operation it carried out.

The troops were used in a way that "did not contribute (to achieving) the goals," he said.

In a radio interview following the resignation, Saguy said that Adam, "and not only him" are responsible for what had happened in the north and that there is a "command and professional crisis " in the army.

"I suggested to the chief of general staff that veteran men (meaning officers) come to help as instructors and perhaps, those of us who are young enough, should come to command," he said.

Some of those shortcomings were a result of the intifada and budget constraints.

Former Chief Reserve Officer, Brig. Gen. in the reserves Ariel Heimann said emergency stores originally prepared for war have been depleted because equipment was taken to confront the intifada. He said had complained to the chief of general staff who justified the removal of equipment. When reservists were called to fight Hezbollah, the equipment was missing.

Troops did not train, tank crews were sent to police the occupied territories rather than prepare for war, and division exercises were conducted only virtually - on computers. Heimann criticized the "Power Point ethos" in which commanders communicate with one another through computer presentations, and sit in front of plasma screens while "there is hardly a change in the soldiers equipment since 1973."

Retired Maj. Gen. Yoram Yair, a paratrooper whose career included command of the 91st division responsible for the Lebanese front, criticized commanders for remaining behind the LCD screens. The commanders' main problem is how to motivate soldiers to fight and, "You must be in the front. It's scary as hell but there is no other way," he said.

Shortly before ground operations escalated, discontent with Adam's performance led Chief of General Staff, Lt. Gen. Dani Halutz to assign his deputy, Maj. Gen. Moshe Kaplisnky, to the Northern Command Kaplinsky, not Adam, was the top man. Adam felt his colleagues stabbed him and in closed meetings said he would quit. His resignation was therefore anticipated.

Channel 1 TV predicted he was "The first domino to fall."

"The campaign was very unfortunate, and I think he won't be the first (to go)," retired Maj. Gen. Amram Mitzna said according to the army radio station. Mitzna headed the Central Command during the first intifada.

Former Defense Minister Binyamin Ben Eliezer, who is now Minister of National Infrastructure, said that Halutz "Must assume responsibility and do exactly what the head of the Northern Command did."

However former head of the Southern Command, retired Maj. Gen. Yom-Tov Samia, said Adam should not leave so fast.

"We've got to draw many lessons from this war... (or else) we'll go to the next war unprepared," he said.

A general who is still in active service, who saw the mistakes and the faults "Knows where the problems are...(and) perhaps can present his own mistakes. It would be easier to draw the lessons with him," added Samia.

Public pressure for a through investigation of the war has meanwhile prompted Prime Minister Ehud Olmert to appoint a investigative committee headed by the former President of the Tel Aviv District Court, Eliyahu Vinograd.

Olmert originally opted for a lesser committee that would include no judge but came under severe criticism for that.

Likewise, Defense Minister Amir Peretz initially appointed a committee of his own that also came under bitter criticism and dissolved. The Cabinet is expected to approve the new committee on Sunday.

Olmert and Peretz may not be the only ones fighting there for their political future. Olmert made Peretz defense minister even though he knew Peretz had no experience in security matters. Peretz, a professional trade unionist, maintains he functioned well during the war and the faults were the responsibility of his predecessor, Shaul Mofaz, who is now minister of transport.

Mofaz said he would produce the minutes of the meetings during the years he had been chief of general staff and defense minister "to show what we did and what we did not do - if we did not do."

Source: United Press International

Related Links
Your World At War



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Analysis: Hezbollah Plans Recovery Timetable
Jerusalem (UPI) Sep 07, 2006
Hezbollah needs "at least two years" to rebuild the capabilities it lost in the war with Israel which is why it is holding fire now, according to a leading intelligence expert. In skirmishes following the cease-fire, Israeli soldiers killed more than 20 Hezbollah guerrillas.







  • European Astrolab Mission Will Help Make Space a Safer Place
  • Space The Next Frontier For Human Being Says ISRO Chairman
  • NASA Selects 12 Research Proposals In Radiation Biology
  • Boston University Awarded NASA Contract To Study Space Radiation

  • Finishing Up Scuff Work And Heading For Emma Dean
  • NASA Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Reaches Planned Flight Path
  • Animated Elevation Model Of Victoria Crater
  • NASA Rover Nears Martian Bowl Goal

  • Arianespace CEO Calls For New Pricing Regime
  • LM Announces Sale Of Its Interests In International Launch Services And LKEI
  • Call For Fair Pricing Policies In The Commercial Launch Services Industry
  • Eutelsat Confirms Sea Launch Agreements For 2008-9

  • Smoke Plume Dispersal From The World Trade Center Disaster
  • Acoustic Data May Reveal Hidden Gas And Oil Supplies
  • DMC International Imaging Wins 2nd Year Contract To Monitor Amazonian Rainforest
  • What Is It Like To Be On A NASA Hurricane Mission

  • Myriad Planets In Our Solar System And Copernicus Smiled
  • CSEPR Examines Movement To Set Aside IAU Planet Definition Ruling
  • Unabashedly Onward to the Ninth Planet
  • Greek Astronomers Take On Xena The Warrior Princess In Planet Name Row

  • Scientists Detect New Kind Of Cosmic Explosion
  • The Eternal Life Of Stardust Portrayed In New NASA Image
  • Cassiopeia A - The Colorful Aftermath Of A Violent Stellar Death
  • AKARI's View On Birth And Death Of Stars

  • Russia And China Could Sign Moon Exploration Pact In 2006
  • SMART-1 Impact Simulated In A Laboratory Sand-Box
  • Smart-1 Impact Flash And Debris: Crash Scene Investigation
  • After The Flash Came The Dust

  • Launch Of Second Galileo Test Satellite Delayed Until 2007
  • Topcon Launches All-New Robotic Surveyor Assistant
  • South Korea And EU Sign Galileo Satellite Cooperation Agreement
  • Uniden Enters Portable GPS Navigation Category

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement