24/7 Space News
The role of history in how efficient color names evolve
stock illustration only
The role of history in how efficient color names evolve
by Staff Writers for UPenn News
Philadelphia PA (SPX) Mar 04, 2024

Suppose two speakers of the same language are playing a guessing game where each has the same color swatches, and Player 1 tries to get Player 2 to guess a hue by naming the color. If the second player consistently guesses correctly as often as possible, that indicates their language has an efficient color naming system.

Past research has shown that efficient color vocabularies are constrained both by how people perceive colors and by how much they want or need to communicate about a given color. For example, Penn researchers found in a 2021 study that the need to communicate about reds and yellows is high across languages, while greens are more important in some languages.

Now, Penn scientists have identified another constraint: history. Colin R. Twomey, interim executive director of the Data Driven Discovery Initiative in the School of Arts and Sciences, worked with psychology professor David H. Brainard and biology professor Joshua B. Plotkin in a new paper showing how a language's past color vocabulary shapes its ability to evolve, shedding light on how the number and meaning of color words have changed over time. Their work is published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

"The main takeaway is that, once you as a linguistic community have an efficient vocabulary, that starting point restricts the next possible efficient vocabulary that you could have when you introduce a new term," says Twomey, the first author. "As the vocabulary grows, the number of different vocabularies that you could move to is increasingly constrained."

This takeaway shares a principle with evolutionary biology. The existence of an evolutionary pathway limits available future pathways, compared to the number of options available if a species were to arise anew. Plotkin and Twomey come from a background in evolutionary theory for biology, and here they are trying to better understand how some of the same theory applies to cultural evolution.

The authors used the publicly available World Color Survey (WCS), in which about 25 speakers from each of 110 languages were asked to name the same set of 330 color stimuli. This dataset provides the likelihood that a speaker from each of the languages would use a certain term to describe a color.

The WCS was the work of anthropologist Brent Berlin and linguist Paul Kay, who identified 11 color categories in English: red, orange, yellow, green, blue, purple, pink, black, white, brown, and gray. While English uses 11 color categories, the most common color vocabulary size among WCS languages is six words.

Using the WCS, the Penn researchers explored the introduction of new terms and the probability that a given word will change meaning as the size of the color vocabulary increases. For example, a term identified as green-blue could shift in meaning to "green" if a new term is established as "blue." Green-blue and blue are quite susceptible to changes in meaning as new terms are added, whereas red, black, and yellow remain relatively stable in meaning.

One example the authors show is a color vocabulary that evolved into a six-word set with red, pink, yellow, black, white, and a green-blue shade. But if one were to make a six-word vocabulary from scratch-de novo-based on the same communicative needs for that language, the vocabulary could instead have separate colors for green and blue and still include red but have no word for pink, and it would still be efficient. Moreover, and despite facing the exact same constraints, from there the historical vocabulary would most likely split green-blue into separate terms whereas the de novo vocabulary is more likely to introduce light green or orange than pink.

"Since we know that history matters, it means we can infer history from the present language state. In principle, we can infer what ancestral color vocabularies were and then compare that to the historical record," Plotkin says. An example he provides is that at certain points in history, certain commercial dyes were introduced that became economically important to a culture.

The paper also notes that history should also constrain how people talk about and categorize aspects of culture aside from color; Plotkin and Brainard respectively point to the ways we categorize consumer products and weather conditions, for example.

Their color study "represents a general theory that categories are refined based on communicative needs, historical constraints, and this principle of efficiency," Brainard says. "The ideas, we would hope, would apply to how we name and categorize and communicate about all kinds of things."

Research Report:History constrains the evolution of efficient color naming, enabling historical inference

Related Links
University of Pennsylvania
Stellar Chemistry, The Universe And All Within It

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters

The following news reports may link to other Space Media Network websites.
Harnessing light with hemispherical shells
Berlin, Germany (SPX) Feb 22, 2024
In a groundbreaking study from Abdullah Gul University in Turkiye, researchers have developed a novel hemispherical shell structure for organic photovoltaic cells, significantly enhancing their light absorption and angular coverage. Published in the SPIE Journal of Photonics for Energy, this innovation could mark a pivotal shift in the quest for more efficient and sustainable solar energy solutions. At the core of this research is a fresh take on the architecture of organic solar cells. Traditiona ... read more

Global patent filings fall for first time in 14 years: UN

Under pressure - space exploration in our time

Modi says India's first astronauts will inspire nation

China Reports Significant Advances in High-End Equipment and Frontier Technology Research

MAPHEUS 14 high-altitude research rocket takes flight

HyImpulse readies SR75 rocket for historic maiden launch in Australia

SpaceX eyes March 14 for next Starship test launch

NASA tests limits of updated engines for future Artemis missions

Study reveals potential for life's building blocks from Mars' ancient atmosphere

Little Groundwater Recharge in Ancient Mars Aquifer, According to New Models

Three years later, search for life on Mars continues

Mining Into Mineral King: Sols 4110-4111

Chang'e 6 and new rockets highlight China's packed 2024 space agenda

Long March 5 deploys Communication Technology Demonstrator 11 satellite

Shenzhou 17 astronauts complete China's first in-space repair job

Tiangong Space Station's Solar Wings Restored After Spacewalk Repair by Shenzhou XVII Team

US and Australia signs Space Technology Safeguards Agreement

SKorea enhances military operations with Iridium connectivity

Turkcell Partners with Lynk for Satellite-Direct Mobile Services in Turkiye

LeoLabs names Tony Frazier as CEO to expand its role in global space operations

New image fusion algorithm enhances multi-dimensional perception

UN, France co-host forum to decarbonise construction sector

Scientists at uOttawa reveal how light behaves in formless solids

Rice lab finds better way to handle hard-to-recycle material

Hold on to your atmospheres: how planet size affects atmospheric escape

CUTE's groundbreaking design paves the way for future small-scale space missions

Earth as a test object

JWST images dispersing gas in a planet-forming disk for first time

New moons of Uranus and Neptune announced

NASA's New Horizons Detects Dusty Hints of Extended Kuiper Belt

NASA's Juno Mission Measures Oxygen Production at Europa

Solved at Pitt: What are Saturn's rings made of?

Subscribe Free To Our Daily Newsletters


The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2023 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. All articles labeled "by Staff Writers" include reports supplied to Space Media Network by industry news wires, PR agencies, corporate press officers and the like. Such articles are individually curated and edited by Space Media Network staff on the basis of the report's information value to our industry and professional readership. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) Statement Our advertisers use various cookies and the like to deliver the best ad banner available at one time. All network advertising suppliers have GDPR policies (Legitimate Interest) that conform with EU regulations for data collection. By using our websites you consent to cookie based advertising. If you do not agree with this then you must stop using the websites from May 25, 2018. Privacy Statement. Additional information can be found here at About Us.