. 24/7 Space News .
Main-Belt Comets May Have Been Source Of Earths Water

Images of the three known main-belt comets (at center of each panel). Other objects shown are stars and galaxies smeared by the motion of the telescope while tracking each comet. Image credit: H. Hsieh and D. Jewitt (Univ. of Hawaii).
by Phil Berardelli
SpaceDaily US Editor
Honolulu HI (SPX) Mar 23, 2006
Three icy comets orbiting among the rocky asteroids in the main asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter could be linked to the origin of Earth's oceans.

The newly discovered comets, called "main-belt comets," hold asteroid-like orbits, and unlike other comets they appear to have formed in the warm inner solar system inside the orbit of Jupiter, rather than in the outer solar system beyond Neptune. Their existence suggests asteroids and comets might be more closely related than previously thought.

"What the (main-belt comet) discovery means, I suspect, is that the snow line was at about 3 AU (Earth distances) or closer at the time when the outer belt objects formed," research team leader David Jewett, of the University of Hawaii, told SpaceDaily.com.

The snow line is the distance from the Sun inside which water can exist as a gas or a liquid, and outside of which it exists mainly as ice. Jewett said the MBCs, as they are called, "accreted outside the snowline, like the short- and long-period comets and all the other icy things in the solar system." He added that the newly found objects suggest where the snowline was during the earliest history of the solar system.

Writing in the March 23 issue of Science Express, Jewett and Hawaii colleague Henry Hsieh said they used the 8-meter Gemini North Telescope on Mauna Kea last Nov. 26 and found that an object they designated Asteroid 118401 was ejecting dust like a comet.

Together with a mysterious comet designated 133P/Elst-Pizarro - known for almost a decade but still poorly understood - and another comet designated P/2005 U1 (discovered by the Spacewatch project in Arizona just a month earlier), 118401 forms an entirely new class of comets.

"The expert dynamicists who have looked at this have not found ways to transform short- or long-period comets into asteroidal orbits," Jewett said. "The reason is that the asteroidal orbits do not allow interaction with Jupiter, so there is no opportunity for the transformation to occur within dynamical schemes."

In other words, the MBCs are unique because they follow flat, circular asteroid-like orbits - not the elongated and often tilted orbits that characterize nearly all other comets. Moreover, their comet-like appearance makes them unlike all other previously observed asteroids.

"In fact, if the MBCs could be derived from comets, then I think one would have to conclude that the whole main asteroid belt could be derived from comets, and nobody is claiming that," Jewett said. "So, we think that they formed in place, with ice that has survived since the accretion epoch."

In both 1996 and 2002, 133P/Elst-Pizarro (named after its two discoverers) was seen to exhibit a long dust tail typical of icy comets, despite having the flat, circular orbit typical of presumably dry, rocky asteroids. As the only main-belt object ever observed to take on a cometary appearance, 133P/Elst-Pizarro's true nature remained controversial.

"The discovery of the other main-belt comets shows that 133P/Elst-Pizarro is not alone in the asteroid belt," Jewitt said. "Therefore, it is probably an ordinary (although icy) asteroid, and not a comet from the outer solar system that has somehow had its comet-like orbit transformed into an asteroid-like one. This means that other asteroids could have ice as well."

Earth is thought to have formed as a hot and dry rocky body, meaning its water content must have been delivered after the planet cooled. Possible candidates for supplying the water are comets and asteroids that impacted the early Earth.

Because of their large ice content, comets were leading candidates for many years, but recent analysis of comet water has shown it is significantly different from typical ocean water on Earth, in terms of its ratio of molecular hydrogen and its heavier isotope, deuterium.

Ice from asteroids could be the solution to the mystery � and future space probes should be able to compare asteroid ice chemically to Earth's water and either prove or disprove the hypothesis.

Jewett said a huge number of impacts from MBCs would be required to furnish all of Earth's water. "Of course, the number is not really what you care about," he added. "The MBCs must occupy a size distribution and a lot of the mass could be contained in a smaller number of objects bigger than 5 kilometers (3 miles)."

He noted that the mass of all the water on the Earth equals about 0.0005 the planet's mass, and previous calculations have suggested that external impacts could have provided that much volume.

The real importance of the discovery, Jewett said, "is that the new objects provide an additional set of icy objects, probably formed much closer to the Sun (3 AU) than either the short- (40 AU?) or long- (20-30AU?) period comets, so we can use them in the future to sample a different piece of the protoplanetary disk."

He said although there is no proof "that the oceans are melted MBCs, but this is certainly possible. Finding the MBCs gives us something to work as we try to address this interesting possibility. Also, it's not very often that you get to find an entirely new class of object in the solar system, so it's very cool from that perspective, too."

Related Links
Hawaii Institute For Astronomy

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Fire In The Ice
League City TX (SPX) Mar 16, 2006
Scientists have analyzed some of the particles captured by NASA's Stardust mission and returned to Earth earlier this year. And they've found a big surprise. Although the particles come from a comet that formed in the deep-frozen outer reaches of the solar system, they contain minerals that could only have been created near the sun.

  • European Space Camp In The Land Of The Midnight Sun
  • Space Tourism Lures A Rising Number Of US Entrepreneurs
  • Resisting Radiation
  • Integral Looks At Earth To Seek Source Of Cosmic Radiation

  • Spirit Churns Up Bright Soil Near McCool
  • Mars Meteorite Similar To Bacteria-Etched Earth Rocks
  • JPL Performs First Two-Antenna Uplink Experiment
  • ITT Supports Successful Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Insertion

  • ATK Rocket Motors Power Successful Launch of Pegasus XL
  • SpaceX To Attempt Falcon Launch Thursday
  • NASA Is 'Three For Three' In Successful ST5 Launch
  • Washington Touts US-Russian Satellite Launch Cooperation

  • NASA Scientist Claims Warmer Ocean Waters Reducing Ice Worldwide
  • Space Tool Aids Fight For Clean Drinking Water
  • FluWrap: Deadly Strain Divides
  • Satellite Flood Mapping Service Strengthens Eastern France Civil Protection

  • "Zero G and I Feel Fine"
  • To Pluto And Beyond
  • New Horizons Update: 'Boulder' and 'Baltimore'
  • New Horizons Set For A Comfortable Cruise Out To Jupiter And Pluto Transfer

  • Chandra Finds Evidence Of How Quasars Ignite
  • Carnegie Scientists Fine-Tuning Methods For Stardust Analysis
  • Ideas On Gas-Giant Planet Formation Take Shape
  • Team Expands Antarctic Neutrino Observatory

  • SMART-1 Tracks Crater Lichtenberg And Young Lunar Basalts
  • Quantum Technique Can Foil Hackers
  • Noah's Ark On The Moon
  • X PRIZE Foundation And The $2M Lunar Lander Challenge

  • New York School Districts Install GPS Tracking Systems in Buses
  • Glonass System To Open For Russian Consumers In 2007
  • TomTom Unveils a Range of New and Updated Content And Services
  • RFID-Based Asset Management With Innovative Sensory Technology

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement