Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .

Is Shenzhou Unsafe?
by Morris Jones
Sydney, Australia (SPX) Feb 16, 2012

File image of the SZ-7 EVA session.

The recent announcement that China will fly its next Shenzhou spacecraft without a crew aboard is a shock. It completely goes against a tide of recent official statements and general feelings within the spaceflight community. It's also represents an abrupt change in status for China's human spaceflight program, which has been making steady strides forward with recent missions.

Last year, China staged its first docking in space, when the uncrewed Shenzhou 8 spacecraft linked up with the Tiangong 1 space laboratory module. The docking test seemed to be highly successful. Video of the mission showed the two spacecraft gently coming together.

A second docking test, performed under more difficult lighting conditions, also seemed to go well. Shenzhou 8 then returned to Earth successfully. All seemed to be right with the mission, setting the stage for a crew to be launched to the Tiangong laboratory on Shenzhou 9 this year.

Recently, there were rumours that the Shenzhou 9 mission would be delayed from its expected March-April launch window to June. This didn't seem to be a big issue. The delay was fairly short, and would probably allow engineers to fix any minor technical issues that could have been revealed on the test flight of Shenzhou 8. We had no indication that anything was seriously wrong.

We now know, thanks to Chinese state media, that Shenzhou 9 will be launched in June, as suspected. But there will be no astronauts on board. This is probably the greatest shock that space boffins have seen from China in years.

Why the sudden change? It seems clear that there must be technical issues at work, and they must be fairly serious.

Statements in the Chinese media hint at performing tests on the small tunnel connecting the Shenzhou spacecraft to the Tiangong module after docking. If we decode the typically vague reportage, it seems fair to assume that there could be some sort of technical problem with the pressurization of this tunnel. This problem could have been exposed during the Shenzhou 8 docking.

There's no doubt that Shenzhou 8 was able to dock successfully. We saw it. But establishing an hermetic seal and a pressurized connection between the two spacecraft is vital. Otherwise, hatches cannot be opened and astronauts cannot move between the two vehicles.

This is a serious problem that could prevent a Shenzhou 9 crew from boarding Tiangong. But that's not really enough reason to remove the crew entirely from the spacecraft. China had previously hinted that the Shenzhou 9 crew could possibly dock with Tiangong but not enter the station.

At the time, this seemed to be a way of hedging China's bets on a successful connection to the module. The crew could dock, then see if they were able to go any further. If they couldn't enter Tiangong, China could still achieve a successful crewed docking and perform some more tests with the Tiangong module.

The crew could also carry out some experiments on board their own Shenzhou spacecraft. This would have been a successful mission, and a step forward from Shenzhou 8.

Removing the crew suggests that the problems run deeper than China has suggested. This author suspects that there could be other issues at work, and raises a serious question: Is Shenzhou safe for astronauts?

Most attention on the Shenzhou 8 mission focused on the docking test. But something else was being tested. Shenzhou 8 was the first "production model" Shenzhou spacecraft, different in design and manufacturing from previous Shenzhou vehicles.

After countless modifications, China had apparently frozen the design of Shenzhou. It had also taken the bold step of manufacturing Shenzhous 8, 9 and 10 nearly simultaneously. This author must now ask if the new-model Shenzhou has some sort of flaw in its basic design or manufacturing.

The reluctance to place a crew on board is certainly an indicator of this. Are there other problems with the spacecraft besides the docking system?

Hopefully, this is not the case. We would love to see a successful mission and a crew on board Tiangong. But the abrupt changes in the mission planning suggest that something is seriously wrong with the Shenzhou program. China hasn't properly explained what is happening. It would be reassuring to all of us if we were given more information. In the meantime, we can hope that Shenzhou 9 successfully irons out the problems that were revealed by its predecessor.

Dr Morris Jones is an Australian space analyst and writer. Email Replace NOSPAM with @ to send email. Dr Jones will answer media inquiries.


Related Links
The Chinese Space Program - News, Policy and Technology
China News from

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Space-tracking ship Yuanwang VI concludes trip
Nanjing, China (XNA) Feb 10, 2012
China's space-tracking ship Yuanwang VI concluded its 154-day trip on Thursday after covering more than 30,000 sea miles. The ship returned to the port of China Satellite Maritime Tracking and Controlling Department in east Jiangsu province. Since September 2011, Yuanwang III, Yuanwang V and Yuanwang VI had sailed out in succession to maritime areas in the Pacific to carry out 12 tac ... read more

China publishes high-resolution full moon map

Manned Moon Shot Possible by 2020

NASA Mission Returns First Video From Lunar Far Side

A Moon Colony by 2020

Martian Carbon Dioxide Clouds Tied To Atmospheric Gravity Waves

NASA kills Mars deal with Europe

No future for Mars?

Scientists say Obama Mars cuts to hit research

Study: 'Crippleware' raises consumer anger

NASA Reaches Higher With Fiscal Year 2013 Budget Request

Sierra Nevada Delivers Flight Test Vehicle Structure

Space tours to the Moon - why not?

Is Shenzhou Unsafe?

Space-tracking ship Yuanwang VI concludes trip

China's new rockets expected to debut within five years

China announces new launch rockets

Russian cosmonauts begin ISS spacewalk

Advanced Communications Testbed for Space Station

Europe's ATV space ferry set for launch to Space Station

Unique Testbed Soon Will Be in Space

Iran mulls base to launch bigger satellites

MASER 12 launched

ILS Proton Successfully Launches SES-4

ESA's new Vega launcher scores success on maiden flight

Searching for Planets in Clouds of Dust

Elements of ExoPlanets

New super-Earth detected within the habitable zone of a nearby star

Russia to Start Own Search for Extrasolar Planets

Cleaning up Earth's orbit A Swiss satellite tackles space debris

Landsat's Thermal Infrared Sensor Arrives at Orbital

Lockheed Martin-Built Milstar Satellite Surpasses 10-Year On-Orbit Design Life

Space debris in the spotlight

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement