. 24/7 Space News .
China's Satellite Destruction Spurs US Space Policy Debate

"Other American experts oppose regulation and argue that US superiority in space should not be shackled in the face of the Chinese threat. Their concern has been bolstered by the fact that the US military in increasingly dependent on satellites for combat operations."
by Jerome Bernard
Washington (AFP) Jan 25, 2007
China's confirmation that it tested an anti-satellite weapon is refueling debate in the United States between proponents of space regulation and those who insist on Washington's absolute free rein. Until now, space has remained largely a zone of cooperation but tensions could grow, especially since satellites are vulnerable to attack, said Theresa Hitchens, director of the Center for Defense Information.

Hitchens is calling for a code of conduct between nations operating in space, despite the aversion of US President George W. Bush's administration for international treaties.

The code-of-conduct approach "is feasible when mutual interests are defined," she explained at a conference organized by the George Marshall Institute in Washington this week.

The Outer Space Treaty, in force since 1967, bans only nuclear arms and other weapons of mass destruction in space.

Since the 1960s, more and more nations have operations in space and today 41 countries have satellites orbiting Earth, Hitchens said.

The United States's superiority in space is currently unequalled but China could threaten it in the coming years, she said.

Bush last year adopted a new space strategy, which some say is highly unilateralist. The policy declares freedom of action by the United States, giving Washington the right to bar from space, if necessary, any country hostile to US interests and to reject any treaty forbidding arms in space.

"A code of conduct can increase freedom of action for responsible actors by restricting harmful actions and behaviors," Hitchens said.

For proof she points to the question of space debris, an issue that has resulted in consensus to limit such debris in satellite launches.

But other American experts oppose regulation and argue that US superiority in space should not be shackled in the face of the Chinese threat. Their concern has been bolstered by the fact that the US military in increasingly dependent on satellites for combat operations.

"The United States must be prepared to defend its sovereign rights by any means necessary," said Baker Spring, an expert at the Heritage Foundation think tank.

He said the US government "should use its diplomatic strength to convince its allies to support in principle the use of military force to counter attempts to deny any state these rights of passage" in space.

Jeff Kueter, the president of the George Marshall Institute, said the United States "should reject any international agreement that would further restrict the use of space to protect national security satellites."

Kueter dismissed diplomatic approaches, such as adoption of a multilateral code of conduct, as "largely camouflage for unverifiable arms control agreements."

"Absent the ability to enforce compliance or punish offenders, a code-of-conduct rule regime may be weak and, more likely than not, ineffectual," he said.

Philip Meek, associate general counsel and director of space law for the US Air Force General Counsel, expressed concern about the idea of international treaty negotiations.

"What is going to be the objective of the other nations in any kind of arms control? The objective is going to bring the United States down to their level," he said.

Meeks said an "informal cooperation" already exists between countries in space. "The issue is how formalized it should be," he said.

Source: Agence France-Presse

Related Links
Military Space News at SpaceWar.com

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

China Officialy Announces Anti Satellite Test Successful
Washington (UPI) Jan 24, 2007
China startled the world Tuesday when it announced its first successful anti-satellite weapons test in space. The Chinese government said it had successfully destroyed one of its own weather satellites with a ballistic missile. The announcement sparked angry protests from the United States and Japan. However, Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Liu Jianchao responding by claiming that his country had displayed a "responsible attitude" and that it had "upheld the peaceful use of outer space," the Russian newspaper Pravda reported

  • Christer Fuglesang Reflects On His Successful Mission
  • Chance For European Student To Join The NASA 2007 Summer Academy
  • Outstanding In-Orbit Performance Of The Terma Star Tracker On TacSat-2
  • Coalition For Space Exploration Names New Leadership

  • HiRise Camera Shows Mojave Crater Peak Is High And Dry
  • A Stellar Moment Frozen In Martian Time
  • Spirit Studies Distinctive Rock Layers With Granules And Platy Beds
  • Opportunity Studies Cobbles And Rock Exposures Around 'Victoria Crater'

  • JOULE II Launches With Success At Poker Flat
  • SpaceWorks Engineering Releases Study On Emerging Commercial Transport Services To ISS
  • Russia To Stop Spacecraft Launches From Far East In 2007
  • SpaceX Delays Launch, Faces New Problems With Static Fire Test

  • New Sensor To Be A Boon To Astronomers
  • Russia's Putin, India Call For 'Weapons Free' Space
  • Space Technology Can Help Ailing Agri Sector: Kasturirangan
  • GeoEye Next-Generation Earth Imaging Satellite Reaches Major Milestone

  • One Year Down, Eight to Go, On The Road to Pluto
  • NASA Spacecraft En Route To Pluto Prepares For Jupiter Encounter
  • Jupiter Encounter Begins For New Horizons Spacecraft On Route To Pluto
  • New Horizons in 2007

  • Uk Astronomer To Lead European Project To Develop A New Roadmap To The Stars
  • Dark Energy May Be Vacuum
  • Integral Sees The Galactic Centre Playing Hide And Seek
  • Hot Windy Nights

  • Lunar Transient Phenomena
  • Russian Space Agency Irked By Moon Program Debate
  • Moon May Be More Like Earth Than Thought
  • Japan Set To Cancel Delayed Moon Probe Mission

  • Russia And India Sign Agreements On Glonass Navigation System
  • South Korea's Port Of Busan To Use Savi Networks SaviTrak
  • Russian Glonass Navigation System Available To India
  • Stolen GPS Lead Police To Thieves

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2006 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA PortalReports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additionalcopyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement