Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




CYBER WARS
US Cyber Head Quits Over Threats To Democracy
by Shaun Waterman
Washington (UPI) Mar 11,2009


Rod Beckstrom

US struggles to pinpoint cyber attacks: Top official
Washington (AFP) March 10 - The United States often cannot quickly or reliably trace a cyber attack back to its source, even as rival nations and extremists may be looking to wage virtual war, a top official warned Tuesday. "It often takes weeks and sometimes months of subsequent investigation," said US intelligence director Dennis Blair, "and even at the end of very long investigations you're not quite sure" who carried out the offensive. China, Russia and other countries already could be potent online foes and terrorists may find it easier in the future to hire hackers to target key systems, Blair told the Senate Armed Services Committee. "Terrorists are interested in using cyberweapons, just the way they're interested in using most any weapon they can use against us," notably to target systems critical to the high-tech driven US economy, he said. "We currently assess that their capability does not match their ambitions in that area, although that's something we have to work on all the time because things become more widespread, terrorists can find hackers to work for them," he said. "It is a concern, but right now I'd say their capability is low and, in addition, I think the more spectacular attacks that kill a lot of people on very publicly is what they are looking for," said Blair. Blair told the panel, which was looking at global threats to US interests, that Washington is "absolutely" trying to speed up what is now the "very slow and painstaking" process of determining who carried out a cyberattack.

The official in charge of coordinating the U.S. government's cybersecurity operations has quit, saying the expanding control of the National Security Agency over the nation's computer security efforts poses "threats to our democratic processes."

Rod Beckstrom, the head of the Department of Homeland Security's National Cyber Security Center, said last week he would be stepping down effective March 13.

In a letter to Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, Beckstrom said the NSA "dominates most national cyber efforts" and "effectively controls DHS cyber efforts through detailees, technology insertions and the proposed move" of the NCSC to an NSA facility at the agency's Fort Meade, Md., headquarters.

"I believe this is a bad strategy on multiple grounds," wrote Beckstrom in the letter, a copy of which was posted on the Web by the Wall Street Journal, which first reported the news. "The intelligence culture is very different than a network operations or security culture. In addition, threats to our democratic processes are significant if all top-level government network security and monitoring are handled by any one organization."

Greg Garcia, who was the Bush administration's first presidentially appointed head of cybersecurity at DHS before leaving last December, told United Press International that, while he did not share Beckstrom's anxiety, "I recognize the cautionary flag he is raising."

Beckstrom's resignation comes as the new Obama administration moves to complete a 60-day review of the way cybersecurity efforts are organized in the U.S. government. Successive administrations have wrestled with the complex problem of how to delineate and define the roles of various intelligence, military and security agencies in assuring the integrity of the nation's computer networks -- the vast majority of which are owned and operated by the private sector and depend for their efficacy on their open and accessible, and therefore security-unfriendly, architecture.

"There's been a lot of duplication and not enough coordination," Jessica Herrera-Flanigan, a former senior congressional staffer on the House Homeland Security Committee, told UPI.

Garcia said there had been "a fairly collaborative partnership, not just between NSA and DHS, but … with a whole lot of moving parts" and different agencies within the government.

"Clearly, both operationally and technologically, the Intelligence Community is a key element," he said, using the insider's terms of art for the sprawling and sometimes fractious collection of spy agencies that serve the U.S. government. But he said DHS' role had to be primary "from a legal standpoint and from a trust and privacy standpoint."

"Unlike the (Department of Defense) or the Intelligence Community, DHS has a statutory responsibility to work across all levels of federal, state and local government and the private sector," he said.

DHS has come under fire for its cybersecurity work, with some criticizing an approach they saw characterized by turf squabbles and overlapping and contradictory lines of authority. Some, including most recently Director of National Intelligence Dennis Blair, have called for a greater role for U.S. intelligence agencies in cybersecurity as a result of the 60-day review, which is being led by an official in Blair's office.

Garcia acknowledged what he called "growing pains" in DHS' cybersecurity efforts, but maintained it would be a mistake to shift primary responsibility for the issue away from the department.

"If there were a move," as a result of the 60-day review, "to centralize or focus cybersecurity strategy on the Intelligence Community, that would jeopardize the relationship we (at DHS) built up over several years with the private sector."

Another Bush administration DHS official, former Assistant Secretary for Policy Stewart Baker, told UPI that although Beckstrom's criticism of the NSA's role was receiving more media attention, "I suspect his frustration was driven as much by the funding and organizational issues as by NSA."

In his resignation letter, Beckstrom wrote that "the NCSC did not receive appropriate support inside DHS. … During the past year, the NCSC received only five weeks of funding, due to various roadblocks engineered within the department and by the Office of Management and Budget."

"He came from a very different background" than most federal officials, said Herrera-Flanigan of Beckstrom, who was a Silicon Valley entrepreneur and author before joining the department.

"There was a big challenge" for him in negotiating "the dynamics between the different players" in the department, she said. "Unless he was given the authorities to coordinate across the department, it would have been a problem," she added.

"Rod is a friend and a remarkable talent," said Baker. "He understood Washington much better than most in Silicon Valley. His inability to move the bureaucracy shows how deep is the divide between government and the tech community."

Department spokeswoman Amy Kudwa told UPI that DHS "has a strong relationship with the NSA … and is fully engaged with the 60-day cybersecurity review. … We look forward to our continued, positive working relationship with all our partners on outreach to the private sector as we strive to further secure our nation's cyber networks.

"We thank Rod for his service, and regret his departure," she concluded.

Neither Beckstrom nor the NSA's public affairs office responded to requests for comment.

.


Related Links
Cyberwar - Internet Security News - Systems and Policy Issues






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








CYBER WARS
Top US cybersecurity official quits
Washington (AFP) March 6, 2009
A top US cybersecurity official has quit, complaining in a resignation letter obtained by Wired magazine that US cyber protection efforts are being dominated by the super-secret National Security Agency. The Department of Homeland Security confirmed the resignation of Rod Beckstrom, director of the National Cyber Security Center, but did not give a reason for his decision ... read more


CYBER WARS
China To Land Probe On Moon At Latest In 2013

Help To Define A Lunar Lander

What Is The Story Behind The Dark Side Of The Moon

Obama's First Budget Backs Core Lunar 2.0 Goals

CYBER WARS
HiRISE Camera Captures Subtle Colors of Mars' Tiny Moon Deimos

Mars Odyssey Reboots Successfully

Mars, Then and Now: Google Mars Update

Spirit Makes Slight Progress on New Route - sol 1831-1837

CYBER WARS
Kazakh Astronaut To Replace Tourist In Russian Spaceship

Iranian President Declares His Country A Space And Nuclear Power

Forum To Explore Why We Should Go To Moon And Mars

Mission Madness Tournament To Vote On Greatest Mission

CYBER WARS
China Able To Send Man To Moon Around 2020

China To Launch 15 To 16 Satellites In 2009

Macao Donates 14 Million Yuan To Mainland Space Program

Scholarships Established For Aerospace Research

CYBER WARS
Station Spacewalkers Install Experiments And Probe

US, Russian spacemen take spacewalk: mission control

Space junk sparks crew scare on ISS

Boeing Hardware To Bring ISS To Full Potential

CYBER WARS
45th Space Wing Set To Launch MilComms Satellite

Ariane 5 Ready For Integration Of Dual Space Science Payload

LRO Launch Update

Herschel And Planck Launch Postponed

CYBER WARS
Kepler Mission Rockets To Space In Search Of Other Earths

Texas Astronomer To Aid Search For Earth-like Planets

NASA launches telescope to seek Earth-like planets

With March 6 Kepler Launch, Work Begins For Berkeley Astronomers

CYBER WARS
Engineers Crack Ceramics Production Obstacle

SSTL Delivers On Russian KANOPUS Missions

Russian General Says US May Have Planned Satellite Collision

Outside View: Radar shield at risk




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement