Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .

GPS court ruling leaves US phone tracking unclear
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Feb 10, 2012

A US Supreme Court decision requiring a warrant to place a GPS device on the car of a criminal suspect leaves unresolved the bigger issue of police tracking using mobile phones, legal experts say.

The top US court ruled 9-0 in January that police violated the rights of a suspected drug dealer when they placed a GPS, or Global Positioning System, tracking device on his vehicle without a warrant and followed his movements.

But privacy activists and legal analysts are watching for guidance on the far more ubiquitous practice of law enforcement tracking using cellphones.

This can be done using a phone's GPS or by "triangulation" using cell towers, and can also be done with certain tablet or laptop computers.

Privacy advocates say real-life police, like the ones on TV, often use this method to track suspects despite the murky legal situation. This could be limited if courts provide clearer rulings or if Congress passes legislation on "location privacy."

"Much government tracking does not involve use of a device planted on a car," said Christopher Slobogin of Vanderbilt Law School.

Slobogin said one study indicated that US police have made eight million requests to phone companies for help in carrying out cellphone tracking.

He said the Supreme Court ruling "leaves much up in the air," but that the justices gave a strong indication they did not like the practice of long-term surveillance without a warrant.

Slobogin said privacy activists should be heartened by the fact that judges across the political spectrum were united on the issue, and in particular by comments from Justice Samuel Alito, whom he called "a very well known conservative who is pro-law enforcement."

Alito held that the tracking using GPS was an "unreasonable search" barred by the constitution's fourth amendment.

Catherine Crump, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union's speech, privacy and technology project, said the January ruling was encouraging even though it did not specifically address mobile phone tracking.

"Five of the justices were extremely concerned about the long-term surveillance of Americans," Crump told AFP. "They felt it violates an individual's reasonable expectation of privacy and that rationale should apply to cellphone tracking."

Crump said authorities can obtain cellphone data in cases of emergencies like kidnappings or escaped criminals, with little controversy. But in investigations, they can often get a subpoena on thin legal grounds instead of what privacy advocates want -- a standard of "probable cause" of a crime.

Yet Crump said she expects no immediately Supreme Court ruling on cellphone tracking because the government, in her view, is pursuing a strategy to avoid an appellate court ruling that would limit its tracking ability.

"The pattern we've seen is that when the government loses, it rarely appeals... as long as a federal appeals court does not rule it needs warrant based on probable cause it can continue to track people based on a lower standard," she said.

Because of this, Crump said the ACLU and other activist groups believe "a legislative solution is necessary."

Several bills have been introduced in Congress, including one by Senator Patrick Leahy, which would call for search warrants to track people in most situations using phones, tablets or other electronic devices.

After the court ruling, Leahy said, "Congress must now do its part to enact this legislation, so that our federal privacy laws keep pace with technology and protect the interests of our nation's citizens."

Gregory Nojeim of the Center for Democracy and Technology, which is part of a coalition supporting enhanced digital privacy, said he believes the top US court would support a high standard in a cellphone case but that Congress should act to clarify this.

"The court's decision in our view sets a constitutional floor for any such clarification" which would require a warrant "when the location monitoring is precise and persistent over time," he said.

But it is not just law enforcement that needs to be clarified, according to privacy advocates.

"Legislation is needed to ensure that companies get meaningful consent from consumers before disclosing information to advertisers and others and to set standards for government tracking," CDT said in a statement.


Related Links
GPS Applications, Technology and Suppliers

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Russia May Spend Almost $12 bln on Glonass in 2012-2020
Moscow (RIA Novosti) Feb 09, 2012
Russia may spend 346.5 billion rubles (almost $12 bln) on its Glonass satellite navigation system in 2012-2020, the Kommersant daily said on Wednesday. Glonass is Russia's answer to the U.S. Global Positioning System, or GPS, and is designed for both military and civilian uses. Government sources told Kommersant space agency Roscosmos and economics ministry had agreed on a draft deve ... read more

China publishes high-resolution full moon map

Manned Moon Shot Possible by 2020

NASA Mission Returns First Video From Lunar Far Side

A Moon Colony by 2020

Spectra Systems Products on Their Way to Mars

Mars Science Lab Computer Issue Resolved

NASA budget will axe Mars deal with Europe: scientists

Mars radar finds possible ocean sediments

Sierra Nevada Delivers Flight Test Vehicle Structure

Space tours to the Moon - why not?

NASA PIT Crews Essential to Commercial Space Endeavor

Jacob Bleacher Gives Free RATS Talk at Library of Congress

Space-tracking ship Yuanwang VI concludes trip

China's new rockets expected to debut within five years

China announces new launch rockets

China's satellite navigation sector annual output predicted to reach 35 bln USD in 2015

Europe's Automated Transfer Vehicle is integrated on Ariane 5

Astronaut Don Pettit Shares Passion for Science from Space

Astronauts seen and heard

Next manned ISS mission to launch May 15: Russia

April new date for SpaceX capsule launch

SpaceX to Launch AsiaSat 6 and AsiaSat 8 in 2014

Mobile Launcher Tests Confirm Designs

Iran to launch new generation of satellites

Elements of ExoPlanets

New super-Earth detected within the habitable zone of a nearby star

Russia to Start Own Search for Extrasolar Planets

Planets Circling Around Twin Suns

Russia to build powerful laser facility

Northrop Grumman Delivers 25,000th Electro-Optic Laser System to U.S. Army

Iran Launches New Home-Made Satellite into Orbit

Ailing Kodak shutters its camera operations

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement