Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




SUPERPOWERS
Commentary: Restoration Doctrine
by Arnaud De Borchgrave
Washington (UPI) Jul 26, 2011


US military chief nominee worried on defense cuts
Washington (AFP) July 26, 2011 - General Martin Dempsey, the nominee to be the next chief uniformed officer of the US military, said Tuesday that major cuts in defense spending would pose a "very high risk" to the United States.

President Barack Obama has proposed $400 billion in defense spending cuts in the next 12 years. Some lawmakers of Obama's Democratic Party have proposed cuts twice as steep as the United States confronts a ballooning US debt.

In his Senate confirmation hearing, Dempsey pledged to "adapt the United States military to a new fiscal reality while ensuring, as my primary responsibility, that America remains immune from coercion."

But pressed on the proposals for steeper cuts, Dempsey voiced concern.

"Based on the difficulty of achieving the $400 billion cut, I believe $800 billion would be extraordinarily difficult and very high risk," Dempsey, who was nominated by Obama as head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told the Senate Armed Services Committee.

Dempsey was responding to concerns from Senator John McCain, the 2008 Republican presidential candidate and staunch military advocate.

"But what concerns me most about our current debate is that the defense cuts being discussed have little or no strategic or military rationale to support them," McCain said.

"They're simply numbers on a page. Our national defense planning and spending must be driven by considered strategy, not arbitrary arithmetic," McCain said.

The proposed defense budget for 2012 is about $671 billion, including $118 billion for the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan.

The budget remains by far the largest in the world. China's defense budget for 2011 is officially $91.7 billion, although experts believe the real figure is significantly higher.

The United States has already hit a debt ceiling of $14.3 trillion. The country will default on August 2 unless Obama and Congress can reach a deal to raise the allowed debt level.

It's now called the Doctrine of Restoration, diplomatic jargon for rebuilding America before China eats our lunch.

After blowing $1 trillion on the Iraq war over the last 10 years and establishing a 1,400-person strong U.S. Embassy in Baghdad only to see Iran emerge with more influence in Iraq than the United States, it is time for Looney Tunes' Bugs Bunny to burst on the national stage and ask, "What's up, Doc?"

We now discover the U.S. taxpayer is funding both sides in Afghanistan through U.S. contracted trucking firms. Contracting waste dug up by Congress totals $34 billion.

Before we blow another trillion on Afghanistan -- it's already close to $500 billion since the U.S. invasion Oct. 7, 2001 -- and encourage European allies to waste more treasure in Libya, it's time for a customized brain fitness plan. We also need cognitive exercises tailored to our geopolitical goals and an estimate of our improvement potential.

A tall order -- but not too tall for a former director of Policy Planning at the State Department and a good bet for future secretary of State. Either a Democrat or a Republican president will need a time-tested geopolitical brain who understands the need to downsize and then rebuild a lean and mean military.

Such a person may be Richard Haass, president of the prestigious Council on Foreign Relations. Under the headline "Bringing Our Foreign Policy Home," Haass writes in Time magazine that "a doctrine of restoration can strengthen the U.S. position abroad by focusing on nation building -- our own."

Brooklyn-born, short-fused, Haass doesn't suffer blowhards gladly. He earned a presidential medal for his work in articulating and developing U.S. policy during Operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm and divided his government service with ranking positions at both State and the Pentagon. From 1989-93, he was special (foreign policy) assistant to President George H.W. Bush.

"The good news," says Haass, "is that there is a doctrine that fits the U.S.'s circumstances. It is one that judges the world to be relatively non-threatening and makes the most of this situation ... The goal would be to rebalance the resources devoted to domestic challenges, as opposed to international ones, in favor of the former.''

Stripped of Aesopian verbiage, this means, "Charity starts at home."

"Doing so," Haass continues, "would not only address critical domestic needs but also rebuild the foundation of this country's strength so it would be in a better position to stave off potential strategic challengers or be better prepared should they emerge all the same."

Haass' term for this doctrine is "restoration": A U.S. foreign policy based "on restoring this country's strength and replenishing its resources -- economic, human and physical."

Under a doctrine of restoration, there would be fewer wars of choice, Haass writes. If any!

America today is in urgent need of a multitrillion-dollar makeover -- from collapsing schools and bridges to a deficient 21st-century air traffic control system.

"Restoration," writes Haass, "is not isolationism (which is) the willful turning away from the world even when a rigorous assessment of U.S. interests argues for acting. Isolationism makes no sense in a world in which the U.S. cannot wall itself off from terrorism, proliferation, protectionism, pandemic disease, climate change or a loss of access to financial, energy and mineral resources."

"An embrace of old-fashioned isolationism would accelerate the emergence of a more disorderly and dangerous and less prosperous and free world," Haass says lest anyone misconstrue the message.

The wars of choice he rejects are Vietnam, the second Iraq war and the current Libyan intervention. Wars of necessity would continue when vital interests are at stake and when there is no alternative to using force.

Afghanistan evolved into a costly war of choice when newly elected President Barack Obama decided to pursue Taliban and not just al-Qaida.

The Restoration Doctrine would quickly drawdown U.S. forces from Afghanistan. Haass' figure: Less than 25,000 troops over the next year and reduce spending by $100 billion.

On Iran, Haass' Doctrine is closer to Israel's when he writes "the U.S. would use or support the use of armed force if it is determined that a military strike could destroy much of Iran's relevant capacity, that doing so would not reduce the chances of meaningful political change inside Iran, that the costs of likely retaliation by Iran were sustainable, that a nuclear Iran could not be confidently deterred and that the proliferation aspirations of others could not be managed."

But Haass's caveats mean the U.S. would keep its powder dry lest Iran's formidable asymmetrical retaliatory capabilities block the strait of Hormuz, send oil prices skyward to $500 a barrel and Western economies into a tailspin. His language was also designed to appease Israel where three retiring heads of intelligence recently warned that Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu favors the bombing of Iran's nuclear facilities.

At home, restoring the fiscal foundation of American power is Haass's top priority; the current situation is unsustainable.

Major cuts in discretionary spending should be a top priority. Such expenditures must be restricted to investments in the United States' human and physical future and competitiveness. This includes "targeted spending on public education, including at the community-college and university levels; modernizing transportation and energy infrastructures; and increasing energy efficiency while decreasing dependence on Middle East oil. Spending cuts should focus on entitlements and defense."

Haass' goal is to reduce the budget deficit by $300 billion per year until the budget is balanced.

The United States can only lead the world, he concludes, if it puts its own house in order first.

.


Related Links
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








SUPERPOWERS
Eyeing China, Clinton urges India to take leader role
Chennai, India (AFP) July 20, 2011
US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton urged India on Wednesday to be more assertive in Asia, reflecting US desire for New Delhi to emerge as a counter-weight to Chinese power. Speaking in the Indian city of Chennai - a southern trading port looking out towards east Asia - Clinton argued that India needed to play a bolder leadership role in building security and prosperity in the region. ... read more


SUPERPOWERS
Unique volcanic complex discovered on Lunar far side

Moon Express Announces Dr. Alan Stern as Chief Scientist

Northrop Grumman Honored by IEEE for Development of Lunar Module

Two NASA Probes Tackle New Mission: Studying The Moon

SUPERPOWERS
NASA's Next Mars Rover to Land at Gale Crater

Opportunity Closing In On Spirit Point At Endeavour Crater

MAVEN Mission Completes Major Milestone

NASA says Mars mountain will read like 'a great novel'

SUPERPOWERS
Graybiel Lab poised for next chapter of space exploration

Space Program Mavens Comment on the Future of Space Exploration

This Time It's Both Rocket Science AND Surgery

NASA Deputy Administrator Is Keynote Speaker At NewSpace 2011

SUPERPOWERS
Spotlight Time for Tiangong

China launches new data relay satellite

Time Enough for Tiangong

China launches experimental satellite

SUPERPOWERS
NASA, SpaceX agree on space station flight

Atlantis crew leaves historic flag aboard ISS

Obama dials for pizza, gets space station

NASA Selects Nonprofit to Manage Space Station National Lab Research

SUPERPOWERS
Russia sends observation satellite into space

NASA inks agreement with maker of Atlas V rocket

Russia launches 2 foreign satellites into orbit

ILS Proton Successfully Launches the SES-3 Satellite for SES

SUPERPOWERS
Distant planet aurorae modeled

Exoplanet Aurora: An Out-of-this-World Sight

Ten new distant planets detected

Microlensing Finds a Rocky Planet

SUPERPOWERS
Sharper deeper faster 3D imaging

Rare Coupling of Magnetic and Electric Properties in a Single Material

China closes two fake Apple stores

Closing In On The Famous Pioneer Anomaly




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement