Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




INTERNET SPACE
Apple, US government spar in antitrust trial finale
by Staff Writers
New York (AFP) June 20, 2013


Apple on Thursday dismissed allegations it conspired to raise the price of e-books and said the US government's antitrust case against it would deter new entrants to concentrated markets.

The two sides delivered closing arguments at the three-week trial, which has shed an uncomfortable light on the technology icon and the clubby world of high-stakes publishing. A decision is expected in the next couple of months.

"The issue in this case is collusion," said Mark Ryan, a Justice Department attorney who outlined the government's case that Apple conspired with publishers to hike prices, costing consumers hundreds of millions of dollars.

The trial focused on a six-week period in late 2009 and early 2010 during which Apple negotiated contracts with publishers ahead of its iPad launch and proposed a new and more profitable business model.

At the time, publishers were furious at the state of the market dominated by Amazon, which sold most bestsellers for just $9.99.

Amazon held "wholesale" contracts with publishers in which it set prices. Apple's contracts shifted to an "agency" model where publishers set the price in exchange for a 30 percent commission to Apple.

Prior to Apple's entry, the publishers -- all of whom have settled in the case -- would complain about Amazon's $9.99 price at private dinners in fancy New York restaurants, but each feared taking on the Internet giant alone.

Apple and the publishers agreed on contracts that let publishers set the price of most bestsellers at $12.99 or $14.99, but Apple won a provision that allowed it to match the prices of Amazon or any other retailer.

As Apple was finalizing its deals, publishers successfully pressured Amazon to accept the agency model and higher prices. Several publishers threatened to withhold e-books from Amazon if it did not go along.

Ryan pointed to testimony from Apple senior vice president Eddy Cue in which he said he knew the publishers wanted to raise prices.

Cue admitted his contracts gave publishers the ability to raise prices and said he provided reassurances about potential Amazon retribution, telling each publisher it would not be alone in signing with Apple.

"This was the publishers acting as a group and Apple bringing that group along," Ryan said. "Only a united industry front could move Amazon off its $9.99 price."

Apple defense attorney Orin Snyder dismissed the government's case as an example of prosecutorial "overreach," saying Apple's conversations with publishers in late 2009 were merely brainstorming sessions.

Snyder pointed out that Cue had almost no phone contact with the publishers from late December until around January 20, 2010, when the talks intensified ahead of the iPad launch.

"There is no such thing as conspiracy by telepathy," Snyder said.

He pointed to the "paucity" of evidence tying Apple to the publishers' negotiations with Amazon and said allegations Apple intended to force them to renegotiate with Amazon were based on "inferences."

Other government evidence was "ambiguous at best," Snyder said.

"There's zero evidence that Apple did anything in these negotiations to enforce collective action."

Snyder warned that a ruling against Apple, a new entrant in a sector dominated by Amazon, would have a "chilling and confounding effect" on business.

Antitrust experts said a key question for the judge is whether Apple convinced the publishers they needed to work collectively to pressure Amazon and whether Apple played a role in facilitating that effort.

Scott Hemphill, a Columbia University law professor who attended part of the trial, said the government's documentary evidence was strong.

Among the most compelling evidence, Hemphill said, were remarks from late Apple chief executive Steve Jobs, who told his official biographer that Apple let publishers raise prices.

Jobs recounted how the publishers told Amazon: "You're going to sign agency contracts or we're not going to give you the books."

The government does not need to show Apple was the "ringleader," or even the "primary coordinator" of a conspiracy, said Daniel Crane, a professor specializing in antitrust at the University of Michigan Law School.

"All they really have to prove is that Apple played some role in furthering the horizontal conspiracy," Crane said.

.


Related Links
Satellite-based Internet technologies






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








INTERNET SPACE
Intelligent glasses designed for professors
Madrid, Spain (SPX) Jun 19, 2013
Scientists at la Universidad Carlos III of Madrid (UC3M) have developed a system based on augmented reality that, thanks to intelligent glasses, enables a professor to see notes or comments on the contents of a lesson and to see if the students understand explanations or if, on the contrary, they are having doubts or difficulties. The proposed system (Augmented Lecture Feedback System - AL ... read more


INTERNET SPACE
Scientists use gravity, topographic data to find unmapped moon craters

Australian team maps Moon's hidden craters

LADEE Arrives at Wallops for Moon Mission

NASA's GRAIL Mission Solves Mystery of Moon's Surface Gravity

INTERNET SPACE
Study: Mars may have had ancient oxygen-rich atmosphere

Opportunity Recovers From Another Flash-Related Reset

ExoMars 2016 Set To Complete Construction

Mars Water-Ice Clouds Are Key to Odd Thermal Rhythm

INTERNET SPACE
NASA Bill Would 'End Reliance on Russia,' Nix Asteroid Capture Project

Britain shut down UFO desk after finding no threat: files

New Zealand emerges as guinea pig for global tech firms

NASA announces eight new astronauts, half are women

INTERNET SPACE
China's space program less costly

China seeks to boost share of satellite market

Space lotuses to touch down in Shanghai

Half-Time for Shenzhou 10

INTERNET SPACE
Accelerating ISS Science With Upgraded Payload Operations Integration Center

Strange Flames on the ISS

Europe's space truck docks with ISS

Russian cargo supply craft separates from International Space Station

INTERNET SPACE
Plan for modified European rocket gets backing

Peru launches first homemade rocket

The Centaur Upper Stage

INSAT-3D is delivered to French Guiana for Arianespace's next Ariane 5 launch

INTERNET SPACE
NASA's Hubble Uncovers Evidence of Farthest Planet Forming From its Star

Exoplanet formation surprise

Sunny Super-Earth?

Kepler Stars and Planets are Bigger than Previously Thought

INTERNET SPACE
New method to distinguish between neighbouring quantum bits

Working backward: Computer-aided design of zeolite templates

Raytheon extends ballistic missile defense capability through radar modernization effort

An innovative material for the green Earth




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement