Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




CIVIL NUCLEAR
Analysis: Nuclear revival without Germany
by Stefan Nicola
Berlin (UPI) Jul 16, 2008


Germany, Europe's largest economy, in 2000 decided to shut down all its nuclear power plants by 2021 -- and some of them even earlier.

Global warming and rising energy prices have sparked a worldwide renaissance of nuclear energy -- but not in Germany, where the grand coalition government is still bickering over the planned phase-out of nuclear power by 2021.

The United States, China, India, Russia, France, Canada, Britain, Finland, Sweden -- the list of countries aiming to build new nuclear power plants or at least extending the running times of older ones is long.

Germany, Europe's largest economy, in 2000 decided to shut down all its nuclear power plants by 2021 -- and some of them even earlier. The one in Biblis in western Germany, built in 1974 and thus Germany's oldest plant, will be taken off the grid as soon as 2010.

The decision to phase out nuclear energy was made at a time when the price for a barrel of oil was roughly $20. It is at nearly $140 today. Coal, which is cheaper but also growing in price, is far from a perfect alternative because of the high carbon dioxide emissions it emits.

Germany has ambitious climate-protection goals, and many experts say the power Germany generates with nuclear energy (some 26 percent) can't be readily replaced by renewables.

That's why the phase-out is now being torpedoed from all sides. Chancellor Angela Merkel is the most prominent supporter of keeping nuclear in the mix -- she wants at least to extend the running times of the safest plants.

Her center-right Christian Democrats and several opposition lawmakers support her, while her coalition partners, the center-left Social Democrats, backed by the opposition Green Party, vehemently oppose those plans. They point to the threat of an accident and its possibly disastrous consequences; to the danger of the proliferation of nuclear weapons; and to the still unsolved issue of how best to deal with nuclear waste.

Merkel nevertheless was pressured by international leaders at the recent Group of Eight summit in Japan to change Germany's nuclear strategy; at the summit Germany was the only nation not to join in the favorable statements toward nuclear energy. Although she would like to do so, she is unable to openly talk about scrapping the German phase-out plan. Before joining forces with the Social Democrats to form Germany's grand coalition government, she signed an agreement that included scrapping nuclear.

Leading industry officials have said Germany needs nuclear energy to guarantee sustainable power generation.

"Nuclear power is the cheapest form of climate protection," Wulf Bernotat, the chief executive officer of German energy giant E.ON, recently told the foreign press corps in Berlin.

Bernotat said that electricity generated by nuclear power is cost-efficient and clean.

"In Germany alone, it avoids roughly 150 million tons of CO2 per year; that's as much as the entire transportation sector emits."

"We should therefore seriously consider extending the running times" of Germany's nuclear power plants, he added.

Critics of nuclear power in Germany say, however, electricity won't become cheaper once running times are extended. They argue that the likes of E.ON are unhappy that some of their biggest cash cows are being shut down.

Merkel's conservatives already have drafted compromise plans to please the other parties. If nuclear power plants are to remain online longer, then energy companies will have to funnel part of the additional profit into so-called sustainability funds that would help pay for energy-efficiency measures and the infrastructure for renewable energy generation.

Yet so far, the Social Democrats are not willing to give up on the phase-out. While some of them are willing to move, there remains a faction inside the government party that sees the phase-out of nuclear energy as an affair of the heart.

Next year Germans will go to the polls and vote for a new government. If Merkel's conservatives could form their favorite government together with the free-market Free Democrats, then nuclear energy would certainly see a revival in Germany as well.

.


Related Links
Nuclear Power News - Nuclear Science, Nuclear Technology
Powering The World in the 21st Century at Energy-Daily.com






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








CIVIL NUCLEAR
IAEA board to discuss India nuclear safeguards next month
Vienna (AFP) July 14, 2008
The UN atomic watchdog's board of governors will meet on August 1st to discuss a draft safeguards agreement with India, the International Atomic Energy Agency said Monday. US President George W. Bush and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh unveiled a controversial agreement in 2005 to share civilian nuclear technology, which would see India enter the fold of global nuclear commerce after ... read more


CIVIL NUCLEAR
Online Casino Reports Bets On Lunar Gambling

Brown-Led Team Finds Evidence Of Water In Lunar Interior

China Almost Done With Map Of Moon Surface

Looking For Early Earth...On The Moon

CIVIL NUCLEAR
Phoenix Claws At Frozen Layer And Drills Small Holes

Ancient Mars Was A Diverse Complex World

Mars Express To Rendezvous With Martian Moon

Phoenix Mars Lander Extends Trench

CIVIL NUCLEAR
UCF Project Selected For NASA Explorer Mission

UK Space Competition Unearths Young Talent

Magellan Aerospace Wins Lockheed Martin Orion Contract

House Passes S And T Bills Commemorating NASA's 50th Anniversary, First Woman In Space

CIVIL NUCLEAR
Shenzhou 7 Shipped To Launch Center For October Launch

China's Shenzhou VII Spacecraft Flown To Launch Center For October Takeoff

China Makes Breakthrough In Developing Next-Generation Long March Rocket

China's Shot Heard Around The Galaxy

CIVIL NUCLEAR
Two Russian cosmonauts begin new space walk

ISS cosmonauts make risky spacewalk for repairs

Russian Soyuz Inspection Spacewalk Under Way

Station Crew Completes Spacewalk Preparations

CIVIL NUCLEAR
Sea Launch Delivers Echostar 11 To Orbit

Countdown Underway For The Launch Of The Echostar XI Satellite

Sea Launch Sets Sail For EchoStar XI Launch

Sea Launch To Put US Telecom Satellite In Orbit Next Week

CIVIL NUCLEAR
Chemical Clues Point To Dusty Origin For Earth-Like Planets

Astronomers discover clutch of 'super-Earths'

Vanderbilt Astronomers Getting Into Planet-Finding Game

NASA Selects MIT-Led Team To Develop Planet-Searching Satellite

CIVIL NUCLEAR
EchoStar XI Satellite Deploys Solar Arrays On Schedule

Eutelsat W5 Satellite Performance Stabilised

Japanese team developing palm-held 3D display

Integral To Provide Carrier Monitoring And Interference Detection Capability To Telenor




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement