Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




THE STANS
Analysis: 'Afghanistan's Plight' book
by Stefan Nicola
Berlin (UPI) Oct 1, 2008


"More and more Afghans believe that NATO will meet the same fate as the Soviet Red Army," Can Merey said. "That's why fewer and fewer Afghans are willing to side with the West. Because after all, who wants to side with a losing team?"

A new book by a German journalist takes an in-depth look at the West's failing attempts to win the war in Afghanistan.

When Can Merey, a German journalist of Turkish descent, in 2003 first traveled to the northern Afghan city of Kunduz, the local people were telling him about their enthusiasm over the arrival of German Bundeswehr soldiers in the city. When he went back to Kunduz earlier this year, hardly anyone was willing to talk to him in public: Paralyzed by a fledgling security and a series of terrorist attacks, the locals today fear Taliban spies and the Taliban's targeted killings of anyone who deals with Westerners. "The people are losing their faith in the West," Merey said earlier this week in Berlin at the presentation of his new book, "The Afghan Plight -- Why the West is on the verge of failing at the Hindukush."

Merey, who is the South Asia correspondent for German news agency dpa, in his book details the current problems the West faces in Afghanistan. He does so not by lecturing from afar, but by speaking to the key actors on the ground -- Western soldiers, Taliban rebels, foreign diplomats, local Afghan businessmen, a detained suicide bomber.

Merey's book is reporting in the best sense -- it includes several chapters detailing Afghanistan's key problems: the corrupt and inefficient government of Hamid Karzai; the drug industry that no one has been able to contain or even destroy; NATO bombings that have led to civilian casualties; Pakistan's secret financing and influencing of the Taliban. He tells the story of a man who wants to join the Taliban together with his two sons, because ISAF troops accidentally killed his third boy; yet Merey's book also makes clear that an overwhelming majority of Afghans want the international presence. "Civil war would ensue if we leave now," Merey said.

"This is a politically important book, and a great one journalistically," said Peter Struck, Germany's former defense minister, who once coined the term that Germany's security must be defended "also at the Hindukush."

Of course, Merey also tackles Germany's own problem with the mission in Afghanistan. Some 3,500 German troops are stationed in the northern provinces, tasked mainly with reconstruction efforts. Germany's Cabinet recently agreed to increase the maximum number of troops in Afghanistan by 1,000 to 4,500 soldiers, a decision the public doesn't like. The military contribution in Afghanistan is very unpopular, mainly because security in the country's northern provinces has dramatically deteriorated, resulting in a growing number of terrorist attacks and German casualties.

Next week German parliamentarians have to renew Germany's contribution (they have to do so every year) and political discussions likely will be heated, with lawmakers from government parties voting against the mission.

Struck and Merey agree that there is no alternative to staying in Afghanistan, which "must not become a safe haven for terrorists again," the former defense minister said. And Merey added: "We have given Afghans our word to stay as long as it takes."

But staying also means improving the overall mission.

Experts agree that the West lacks a coherent strategy; an update of that -- taking into account regional differences in Afghanistan -- should be drafted once a new U.S. president takes office in January, said Citha Maas of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs, a Berlin-based think tank.

Merey in his book argues that Washington should fight corruption by pressuring the Karzai government into better behavior (and by increasing salaries of civil servants); that police training, which has been tried unsuccessfully by Germany, should be enforced; that NATO or U.S. troops need to fight opium poppy cultivation; that regional powers, such as Iran and -- most importantly -- Pakistan need to be included to support the West's struggle; that NATO members need to abolish caveats that undermine military efficiency; and that they more strongly communicate that they are willing to finish the job.

"More and more Afghans believe that NATO will meet the same fate as the Soviet Red Army," Merey said. "That's why fewer and fewer Afghans are willing to side with the West. Because after all, who wants to side with a losing team?"

.


Related Links
News From Across The Stans






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








THE STANS
US drone strike kills eight militants in Pakistan: officials
Miranshah, Pakistan (AFP) Oct 1, 2008
A missile fired by a suspected US drone hit a house in a Pakistani tribal area bordering Afghanistan, killing at least eight Islamist militants, mainly Arabs, officials said Wednesday. The overnight attack was the latest in a string of incidents on the rugged frontier that have raised tensions between Islamabad and Washington, including a recent clash between Pakistani troops and US-led ... read more


THE STANS
NASA's Dirty Secret: Moon Dust

NASA Challenges Students To Design Tools For Moon Rovers

A Lunar Dust Up Could Spell Trouble

Company Launches Moon Dust Pens Website

THE STANS
Nicaraguan Volcano Provides Insight Into Early Mars

Mars Lander Sees Falling Snow, Soil Data Suggest Liquid Past

MRO Reveals Rock Fracture Plumbing On Mars

The Ancient Rains Of Mars

THE STANS
Magnetic Hunger Could Drive Space Travelers Insane

Successful Re-Entry Marks Bright Future For ATV

Astronaut vs. Earthlings chess game begins

Commercial space ventures ready for lift-off

THE STANS
China hails spacewalk 'heroes' and sets eyes on moon

China plans manned trip to moon after successful mission

China astronauts return as heroes after historic spacewalk

China spacewalk fires national pride

THE STANS
Boeing Receives ISS Contract Extension

Europe's "space truck" heads for Pacific breakup

Russia's Space Agency Confirms 18th ISS Expedition

The US Has No Option But To Use Russia's Soyuz Craft

THE STANS
Russia Launches Thai Satellite On Converted Missile

Sea Launch Successfully Delivers Galaxy 19 To Orbit

Sea Launch Countdown Underway For The Galaxy 19 Mission

ArianeSpace Buys 10 Soyuz Rockets For Kourou Spaceport

THE STANS
Worlds In Collision

US astronomers discover inter-planetary collision

NASA's Kepler Spacecraft Baked And Ready For More Tests

TNO Star Separators Help ESO With Detection Of Exoplanets

THE STANS
Actel Adds DSP Capabilities To Industry-Leading RTAX Space FPGAs

New Research Shows Why Metal Alloys Degrade

Oracle, HP unveil computer to cope with digital explosion

Microsoft courts Chinese consumers with slashed software price




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement