. 24/7 Space News .
  • Opinion piece's are invited for publication: email us
  • The Space Age Born Of
    The Cold War Is Over

    The official NASA Columbia STS-1 Lift Off Release.
  • Desktop Image Version
  • by Bruce Moomaw
    Los Angeles - Feb 02, 2003
    Today's appalling Shuttle tragedy proves -- once again -- that manned spaceflight, at this point in history, is not remotely worth either its cost or its risk of lives. I say "once again" because virtually any scientist worth his salt has been pointing out that fact routinely for decades.

    Any skeptic is invited to take a look at what the professional science journals regularly say on this subject.

    NASA has always been warped by the freakish circumstances of its early development.

    The Moon Race was originally promulgated by Vice President Lyndon Johnson in 1961 (as he told his friends openly) in order to try to pump more federal money into the South in general and Texas in particular. He managed -- narrowly -- to persuade JFK to go along (the only subject upon which he ever seems to have had any significant influence on Kennedy's administration as Vice President).

    Regardless of whether one regards the political goals of the Moon race as worthwhile, it is unquestionable that -- ever since the Apollo program ended -- NASA has been frantically trying to maintain the grotesquely bloated levels of funding it received during those days. It has managed to do so, by a two-stage process.

    First, it has told one deliberate and outrageous lie after another about the supposed cheapness and utility of first the Space Shuttle and then the Space Station (overestimates, in both cases and both categories, of over 10 to 1!) in order to narrowly persuade the White House and Congress to initiate both programs.

    As one former NASA official told a "Time" magazine reporter shortly after the Challenger disaster, regarding NASA's lies to gain initial approval of the Shuttle in 1972: "We hated to do it, but we were getting SO many votes."

    NASA has then resorted, over all the following years, to the time-honored "camel's nose" technique of methodically raising its cost estimate and lowering its usefulness estimate for each program by a little each year, while simultaneously insisting that if Congress didn't go on funding the program ANYWAY, the money already spent would have been wasted.

    As a swindle, this has worked magnificently -- in both cases, by the time the rubes have finally caught on to the game, tens of billions in unjustified funding has been pumped into the aerospace-industrial complex.

    Ultimately, of course, the game always unravels. The Challenger tragedy was a direct result of the fact that NASA didn't dare stop launching Shuttles long enough to fix a whole flock of serious design programs which it knew existed -- including a problem with the landing brakes even more serious than the problems with the solid booster O-rings -- because, even by 1986, it was still desperately trying to continue pretending to Congress that the Shuttle could be flown at least a dozen times a year at an acceptable cost.

    After it finally became impossible to sustain that lie in the wake of Challenger, NASA switched to saying that the Shuttle program was justified entirely to support the Space Station (if for no other reason).

    The supposed usefulness of the Station itself is a comparable lie which has been steadily uncovered to a greater and greater degree for the last 15 years or so -- but never quite fast enough for the Station ever to be canceled (primarily due to its elementary political appeal as pure home-district pork for Congressmen).

    The new tragedy today may change that. At a minimum, it proves that NASA's post-Challenger estimate of Shuttle safety has been as psychotically inaccurate as its pre-Challenger estimates -- with both estimates quite possibly being another set of deliberate lies.

    NASA's current estimate has been that the Shuttle has only one chance in 350 of suffering a fatal accident during a launch, and considerably less of a risk during reentry.

    Not quite true. If -- as seems increasingly likely -- the Columbia disaster was due to detachment of some of its crucial belly tiles, then -- whether this was actually due to impact by a lightweight piece of debris from the external tank during launch or not -- it indicates that the Shuttle's entire reentry thermal protection system is incredibly fragile, and always has been.

    There is also a genuine chance that today's tragedy will turn out to be due to excessive economizing on Shuttle maintenance and safety programs -- economizing which was criticized, explicitly and at length, by both the House and Senate Appropriations Committees last year -- in order to make it possible to continue funding the Space Station, even in some kind of barely scientifically usable form.

    The simple fact is that the average manned spaceflight costs about 10 times as much as the average unmanned space mission, for much LESS scientific and commercial return -- and always has.

    As President Reagan's science advisor George Keyworth said: "While all government agencies lie part of the time, NASA is the only one I know of that does so routinely." The reason is simply that it has far less reason to exist at anything remotely like its current funding levels than any other U.S. government agency does.

    NASA has been running an gigantic swindle on US taxpayers for at least the past three decades -- at the cost of about $150 billion in unjustified spending, and now a total of 14 human lives.

    All we can hope for at this point, however, is that the White House and Congress will finally come to their senses and shut the American manned space program down, completely, until radical new technology allows massive improvements in both launch cost and flight safety -- a development which is at least two decades or so off -- while maintaining (or even increasing) its spending both on unmanned space exploration and on that development of aeronautical technology which has supposedly been one of its primary reasons for existing.

    This hope, however, is based on the assumption that the federal government possesses a significant degree of brains and honesty, which has always been open to serious question.

    Editor's Note: Bruce in his original note to me advising that he had written this, said as follows:

    ...is the following, which I wrote (almost exactly as follows) to a liberal blogsite printable. You will be able to tell from the tone that I was white-faced with rage when I wrote it, but I stand by every word in it, and if you want to print it as my official editorial on this subject, go ahead."

  • Opinion piece's are invited for publication: email us

  • Headlines From Today.   -   see quick list for very latest
  • South African "space tourist" Shuttleworth mourns Columbia crew
  • Turkey extends condolences over Columbia disaster
  • War-scarred Israel mourns loss of first astronaut in shuttle disaster
  • US mourns Columbia crew as NASA seeks answers to cause of tragedy
  • Columbia loss brings astronaut death toll to 21
  • Russia to launch space vessel Sunday despite Columbia tragedy
  • Shuttle landings always fraught with peril: experts
  • Asia grieves Columbia disaster, first Indian-born woman astronaut
  • European rivals join in mourning for loss of US shuttle
  • Israel to send more astronauts into space despite tragedy: PM
  • New Zealand prime minister mourns Columbia disaster
  • Malaysia saddened over Columbia disaster
  • Americans gripped with grief at loss of Columbia seven
  • China regrets Columbia disaster, says exploration should continue
  • South Korean president voices condelences over Columbia
  • India grieves for shuttle astronaut Kalpana Chawla
  • Progress space vessel to be launched as scheduled Sunday: official
  • Residents in town where debris rained down pay respects to Columbia's dead
  • China's President voices "deep regret" over Columbia shuttle disaster
  • Taiwan voices condolences over US shuttle disater
  • Shuttle landings difficult at best
  • Israeli ambassador mourns shuttle crew loss
  • Japan's space agency offers aid after shuttle disaster
  • Australian "spidernauts" aboard Columbia space mission
  • China's President voices "deep regret" over Columbia shuttle disaster
  • US mourns new shuttle disaster as Columbia disintegrates
  • Columbia crew remains found: Texas police
  • NASA suspends space shuttle flights
  • NASA, Texas officials secure shuttle Columbia debris
  • Bush declares emergency in parts of Louisiana and Texas
  • EU extends condolences to the US on Columbia accident
  • Columbia tragedy could end the Shuttle programme: British press
  • Americans gripped with grief at loss of Columbia seven
  • NASA suspends space shuttle flights
  • US mourns new shuttle disaster as Columbia disintegrates
  • Australia expresses deep sympathy over shuttle disaster
  • Space shuttle disaster jars jumpy Americans
  • Space shuttle disaster risks major delays for space station
  • Australia expresses deep sympathy over shuttle disaster
  • Space shuttle disaster jars jumpy Americans
  • Space shuttle disaster risks major delays for space station
  • Texas authorities investigating reported attempts to sell shuttle debris
  • Space Shuttle loss horrible tragedy for Israel
  • World leaders react with grief to shuttle loss
  • Doomed shuttle crew includes two women and first Israeli in space
  • NASA suspends space shuttle flights
  • Bush mourns loss of Columbia, lauds crew
  • Columbia crew saw problems before disaster struck: NASA
  • French astronaut says Columbia should no longer have been used
  • Sharon phones astronaut's father in wake of space shuttle disappearance
  • Shuttle's long, risky flight leaves no room for error
  • Astronauts fell in the pursuit of a better life on Earth: Sharon
  • Bush orders flags flown at half-staff on government buildings
  • US space shuttle disintegrates upon returning to Earth
  • Debris struck wing of Columbia at take-off: NASA
  • ISS Team Has Adequate Supplies: NASA
  • Debris Struck Wing Of Columbia At Take-Off: NASA
  • Grief Etched On Faces Of Visitors To National Air And Space Museum
  • Columbia Crew Saw Problems Before Disaster Struck: NASA
  • NASA, Texas Officials Secure Shuttle Columbia Debris
  • Canada'S PM Chretien Expresses "Deep Sadness" Over Columbia Shuttle Tragedy
  • NASA Suspends Space Shuttle Flights
  • Sharon Phones Astronaut'S Father In Wake Of Space Shuttle Disappearance
  • Bush Consoles Columbia Crew'S Families
  • NASA Starts Huge Inquiry Into Columbia Disaster
  • Columbia disaster worse than Challenger tragedy: French astronaut
  • US House to fly US flag at half-staff for Columbia crew
  • Arafat sends condolences to Bush, victims' families over space tragedy
  • Bush discusses shuttle tragedy with world leaders
  • Radio message gave no clue to Columbia disaster
  • Space station astronauts not stranded by Columbia disaster: ISS official
  • Headline
  • World leaders react with grief to shuttle loss
  • Chronology for NASA's space shuttle series
  • US space exploration will continue despite loss of Columbia: Bush
  • NASA working with eastern Texas authorities to secure debris
  • US space shuttle disintegrates upon returning to Earth
  • India mourns shuttle astronaut Kalpana Chawla
  • Lost Columbia crew had commemorated previous NASA deaths
  • Columbia disaster a "tragic day" for US: NASA
  • Russian space agency offers to assist Columbia investigation
  • Columbia disaster may lead to suspension of ISS: Russian expert
  • UN's Annan expresses regrets over Columbia tragedy
  • Astronauts dread a day like this: Canadian Space Agency president
  • Ill-fated Columbia mission was 16-day laboratory in space
  • Space shuttle landing process
  • In Texas, flash, rumble, thick fog, say witnesses to Columbia break-up
  • Headline
  • Failure of heat resistance system may have caused shuttle disaster: expert
  • Bush puts White House in crisis mode after shuttle loss
  • Text of NASA statement after loss of space shuttle Columbia
  • Indian-born astronaut aimed at the moon
  • No sign of terrorism in Space Shuttle Columbia's disappearance: FBI
  • Space shuttle Columbia lost 17 years after Challenger tragedy
  • Columbia: the oldest of US space shuttles Related Links
    Search SpaceDaily
    Subscribe To SpaceDaily Express
     Media Hype Alone Cannot Fuel The Space Program
    Los Angeles - Jan 21, 2003
    It seems to be the week for excessive hype where space is concerned. Over the last few days, three separate stories about developments and problems in space exploration have made a considerable splash -- but on more detailed inspection, all three have been overblown.

    Scrap The Shuttle Program
    by Carlton Meyer
    Editor G2mil.com
    Richmond - Nov 01, 2002
    The US military considers control of outer space vital to future warfare. Spaceprojects.com noted that page 18 of this Commerce Department report (pdf) documents how the USA slipped to just 29% of the world's launch market share in the year 2000, even though we had 48% of it in 1996, and apparently all of it the decade before.

    Thanks for being here;
    We need your help. The SpaceDaily news network continues to grow but revenues have never been harder to maintain.

    With the rise of Ad Blockers, and Facebook - our traditional revenue sources via quality network advertising continues to decline. And unlike so many other news sites, we don't have a paywall - with those annoying usernames and passwords.

    Our news coverage takes time and effort to publish 365 days a year.

    If you find our news sites informative and useful then please consider becoming a regular supporter or for now make a one off contribution.
    SpaceDaily Contributor
    $5 Billed Once

    credit card or paypal
    SpaceDaily Monthly Supporter
    $5 Billed Monthly

    paypal only

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2016 - Space Media Network. All websites are published in Australia and are solely subject to Australian law and governed by Fair Use principals for news reporting and research purposes. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA news reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement, agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement All images and articles appearing on Space Media Network have been edited or digitally altered in some way. Any requests to remove copyright material will be acted upon in a timely and appropriate manner. Any attempt to extort money from Space Media Network will be ignored and reported to Australian Law Enforcement Agencies as a potential case of financial fraud involving the use of a telephonic carriage device or postal service.