Space News from SpaceDaily.com
Fears of greenwashing from Paris climate deal architect
Glasgow, Nov 8 (AFP) Nov 08, 2021
As France's top negotiator leading up to the Paris Agreement, Laurence Tubiana was one of the main architects of a deal that aimed to steer the world away from climate change disaster.

The 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change called for capping global warming at well below 2 degrees Celsius above the pre-industrial level, and ideally closer to 1.5C.

Now head of the European Climate Foundation, Tubiana remains a key player in crafting global climate policy and ensuring that the deal is implemented, including at the COP26 summit in Glasgow.

AFP interviewed Tubiana by telephone at the weekend on the sidelines of the UN talks. Her answers have been condensed and edited for clarity.


- You have said greenwashing is the new climate denial. What does that mean? -


I am of course happy about the many 2050 net-zero commitments, both from governments and the private sector. It was a target of the Paris Agreement, and it is great that this is now the benchmark.

But most of these commitments cannot be verified. There is no mechanism for ensuring delivery, no capacity or authority to check these claims.

Then there is the role of offsets. (Credits for planting trees or other carbon-reducing actions that can be bought to compensate for emitting C02 or other greenhouse gases).

Many companies -- especially oil and gas firms -- include a lot of offsets in their net-zero plans. But there is solid research showing offsets currently don't deliver any substantive emissions reduction. If that is true then this is a form of cheating. This is why I say greenwashing is the new climate denial.

It is dangerous because it undermines the companies and financial investors that are actually reducing their emissions.

In the end, greenwashing delays climate action because it tempts others to say: If this oil & gas is still producing massively in 2050 by using offsets, why should I do anything?"


- What do you think about the major announcements so far at COP26?-


These are voluntary commitments with no real legal framework, no peer-review pressure. So we don't know how they will be implemented.

That said, some are quite significant.

The declaration to end deforestation by 2030 is not as new as claimed, but is much better than the one in 2014.

I think the methane announcement -- more than 100 countries agreeing to collectively cut methane emissions 30 percent by 2030 -- is very promising, even if the biggest methane emitters have not signed up.

But we need a legal instrument -- a protocol -- for methane, like the one we have for HFCs (hydrofluorocarbons, a powerful manmade greenhouse gas).

A third significant announcement -- which came before COP26 -- was that of South Africa's 2030 and 2050 targets for reducing greenhouse gases.

And now, with the $8.5 billion in support from EU countries, plus the UK and potentially the US, there's a financial instrument to back them up.

An announcement on phasing out coal is a lot shakier, and not that clear. We have already seen Poland backtracking, and South Korea is finally not sure they are happy to have signed.


- How do these announcements relate to the UN climate negotiating process? -


Glasgow could become the city of two tales.

One is a tale of fantastic mobilisation and progress. The other one -- which we see with the protests in the street -- says that it's not really happening and companies are just cheating.

If we don't have something to bridge that difference, it will be very difficult to have an agreement.

Benchmarks and commitments that rely only on the goodwill of the actors -- that will not work.

For me credibility and accountability are the keys words for this week.


ADVERTISEMENT




Space News from SpaceDaily.com
NASA and DOE plan fission power plant on Moon by 2030
Berkeley Scientists set to home in on 100 signals from Seti at Home
Firefly prepares Alpha Block II upgrade for Flight 8

24/7 Energy News Coverage
Scientists uncover new quantum state that could power future technologies
Self-healing composite can make airplane, automobile and spacecraft components last for centuries
Pendulum device taps power from ocean currents

Military Space News, Nuclear Weapons, Missile Defense
GE and Lockheed validate compact rotating detonation ramjet for hypersonic missiles
Danish PM says Greenland showdown at 'decisive moment' after new Trump threats
Russia claims Oreshnik missile hit Ukrainian aviation plant

24/7 News Coverage
Cosmic krypton timestamps reveal Australia landscape evolution and resources
Fire on Ice: The Arctic's Changing Fire Regime
Warming trend to intensify crop droughts across Europe and beyond


All rights reserved. Copyright Agence France-Presse. Sections of the information displayed on this page (dispatches, photographs, logos) are protected by intellectual property rights owned by Agence France-Presse. As a consequence, you may not copy, reproduce, modify, transmit, publish, display or in any way commercially exploit any of the content of this section without the prior written consent of Agence France-Presse.