Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .

The quantum coin toss
by Staff Writers
London, UK (SPX) Feb 21, 2013

50:50 chance, but is it classical or quantum?

All unpredictability in the world around us, be it the outcome of a coin flip or the weather conditions a month from now, is a fundamentally quantum rather than classical phenomenon.

This is the conclusion of two physicists in the US, who have worked out that molecular interactions in gases and liquids can amplify tiny quantum fluctuations, to the point where the fluctuations are large enough to account for the uncertainties we experience at the macroscopic scale.

This insight, they argue, could prove important in cosmology, as it might rule out some theories of the multiverse that rely on classical as opposed to quantum probabilities.

In classical theories of probability the chances we attribute to a flipped coin landing either heads-up or tails-up simply reflect how much or how little we know about the coin flipping. To say that there is a 50:50 chance means we have no idea how the coin will land.

In principle, however, if we understood exactly which physical processes determine the outcome of the flip and also know with enough precision all of the relevant parameters - such as the force imparted to the coin, the height at which it lands and the air resistance - we could predict the outcome with certainty.

According to the latest research, this view is not correct. Andreas Albrecht and Daniel Phillips of the University of California at Davis argue that the probabilities we use in our everyday lives and in science do not "quantify our ignorance" but instead reflect the inherently random nature of the physical world as described by quantum mechanics.

They maintain that quantum fluctuations can be amplified sufficiently by known physical processes to the point where they can entirely account for the outcome of these everyday macroscopic events. In fact, they claim that all practically useful probabilities can be accounted for in this way. In other words, all classical probabilities can be reduced to quantum ones.

To back up their case Albrecht and Phillips consider an idealized fluid of billiard-ball-like molecules that continually collide with one another. The Heisenberg uncertainty principle dictates that the trajectory of a billiard ball will have an inherent uncertainty, resulting from the uncertainties in its position and momentum.

The researchers worked out - by inputting suitable values of radius, mean free path, average speed and mass of the billiard balls into a couple of simple equations - how much this uncertainty grows with each collision between the balls. They show that in water and air (nitrogen) the uncertainty becomes so large in the space of one collision that every single fluctuation in the properties of these fluids has a fully quantum-mechanical origin.

Quantum outcomes
The researchers then show that the quantum fluctuations manifest in the water can wholly determine the outcome of a coin flip. They calculate that a typical flipped coin can spin through half a revolution in about 1 ms.

This is also the temporal uncertainty in the neuronal process governing the coin flipping, a process that a group of neuroscientists in 2008 argued is caused by fluctuations in the number of open neuron ion channels.

Since these fluctuations are, in turn, caused by the Brownian motion of molecules called polypeptides in a fluid that is largely water, quantum uncertainty (which drives the Brownian motion) can completely randomize the coin flipping.

Cat's tail
As such, the researchers say that anyone tossing a coin is, in fact, performing a Schrodinger's cat style experiment. But rather than a cat that is both alive and dead, the quantum object in this case is a coin, the final state of which is simultaneously heads and tails. The outcome of the flip therefore remains genuinely open until the upwards face of the coin is looked at, at which point the system takes on a definite value of either heads or tails.

The researchers admit that their example is very simplified and that they would have a hard job tracing the amplification of quantum uncertainties in all familiar contexts, be it rolling dice or picking out a card at random. They also point out that it would only take one counterexample to falsify their idea - a use of classical probabilities that is clearly isolated from the physical, quantum world.

David Papineau, a philosopher at King's College London, believes that Albrecht and Phillips are likely to be correct but he doesn't think their conclusion is terribly surprising. "It is very likely that all serious probabilities, be it a coin landing heads-up or a child being female, are manifestations of quantum chanciness," he says. "Indeed we have devices, such as Geiger counters, that show how big results are often caused by chancy micro-events."

Albrecht replies that he and Phillips are perhaps the first physicists to have tackled the relationship of quantum and classical probabilities head-on, and he argues that the latest research might also rule out some theories in which physical processes (such as "eternal inflation") produce multiple copies of pocket universes like the one we observe around us.

Such theories of the "multiverse", he says, need to import purely classical probabilities because a quantum wave function on its own cannot determine in which universe a particular measurement would be made. But Albrecht points out that such a move would not be possible if classical probabilities are, at root, quantum.

A preprint of the research is available on arXiv.


Related Links
Institute of Physics
Understanding Time and Space

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

First Three-Year LHC Running Period Reaches A Conclusion
Geneva, Switzerland (SPX) Feb 18, 2013
At 7:24 a.m., the shift crew in the CERN [1] Control Center extracted the beams from the Large Hadron Collider, bringing the machine's first three-year running period to a successful conclusion. The LHC's first run has seen major advances in physics, including the discovery of a new particle that looks increasingly like the long-sought Higgs boson, announced on 4 July 2012. And during the ... read more

Building a lunar base with 3D printing

US, Europe team up for moon fly-by

Russia to Launch Lunar Mission in 2015

US, Europe team up for moon fly-by

NASA Rover Confirms First Drilled Mars Rock Sample

India plans mission to Mars in 2013

Rover finds gray rock beneath Red Planet's surface

Bleach could hamper Mars life search

NASA plant study headed to space station

NASA Spinoff 2012 Features New Space Tech Bettering Your Life Today

Orion Lands Safely on Two of Three Parachutes in Test

Supersonic skydiver even faster than thought

Welcome Aboard Shenzhou 10

Reshuffle for Tiangong

China to launch 20 spacecrafts in 2013

Mr Xi in Space

NASA briefly loses contact with space station

Temporary Comm Loss Interrupts Crew's Day

Low-Gravity Flights Will Aid ISS Fluids and Combustion Experiments

Progress docks with ISS

NASA Seeks University Participants for Summer Rocket Workshop

Another Sea Launch Failure

ILS Concludes Yamal 402 Proton Launch Investigation

Ariane 5 delivers record payload off back-to-back launches this week

Searching for a Pale Blue SPHERE in the Universe

Earth-like planets are right next door

Direct Infrared Image Of An Arm In Disk Demonstrates Transition To Planet Formation

Kepler Data Suggest Earth-size Planets May Be Next Door

Engineers show feasibility of superfast materials

Sony bills PS4 console as gaming's future

Lessons from nature could lead to the creation of new materials

'Explorers' to don Google Internet glasses

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement