Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .

No truce expected in global patent wars
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Sept 11, 2011

Patent reform legislation passed by the US Congress may represent the most sweeping changes to the law in decades but the bill is not expected to end the courtroom wrangling between technology giants.

"My feeling is that it won't change the dynamics much of the ongoing patent wars," said Roger Kay of Endpoint Technologies Associates. "The problem is with patents in general, in that there's way too much patenting and people patent any old thing including how to toast bread."

Ed Black, president and chief executive of the Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA), said the bill, the America Invents Act, "doesn't effectively address the real serious problems of our patent system.

"The bill tinkers in various ways -- some things are good, some things are bad -- but it's not a gamechanger," Black said, agreeing with Kay that the main problem is "too many patents issued that are simply not high-quality patents."

Black noted that the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) announced recently that it has issued its eight millionth patent.

"Most people think of patents as being like Edison and the light bulb," he said. "Tell me we've had eight million game-changing ideas."

The Senate passed the America Invents Act on Thursday by an 89-9 vote. It cleared the House of Representatives earlier this year by a similarly lopsided 304-117 margin.

Democratic Senator Patrick Leahy, a key author of the legislation, said the bill will "ensure that inventors large and small maintain the competitive edge that has put America at the pinnacle of global innovation."

The legislation notably shifts the granting of US patents from a "first to invent" system, which left considerable leeway for interpretation, to a "first to file" basis and seeks to reduce a backlog of 750,000 applications.

Another goal is to curb costly litigation but technology industry analysts tend not to see that happening anytime soon.

Patent lawsuits are a frequent occurence among smartphone and tablet computer makers in particular and the world's best known brands are ensnared in a complex web of legal claims spanning the globe.

Just a day after the passage of the bill, Apple managed to get a German court to ban South Korea's Samsung from selling its Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet computer in Germany, ruling it had copied the iPad.

Apple recently settled a patent dispute with Finland's Nokia by entering into a licensing agreement and is embroiled in a series of suits and counter-suits with Taiwan's HTC, which accuses the California company of violating HTC-held patents in its Macintosh computers, iPods, iPhones, iPads and other products.

Google, meanwhile, is being sued by US business software giant Oracle over technology used in its Android mobile operating system and said earlier this year that Android is the target of a "hostile, organized campaign" by Apple, Microsoft and Oracle being waged with "bogus patents."

Last month, Google purchased US handset maker Motorola Mobility -- and its portfolio of 17,000 patents -- for $12.5 billion in a move chief executive Larry Page said was partly intended to "better protect Android from anti-competitive threats from Microsoft, Apple and other companies."

Independent technology analyst Carmi Levy said the patent reform bill is the "best step the US government has taken toward cleaning up the USPTO backlog (and) eliminating frivolous, competition-killing lawsuits and litigation."

"But it's only the first," Levy said. "It would be naive of us to assume that the effects of decades of woefully obsolete patent law will suddenly vanish as US businesses seamlessly transition into the new regime.

"Expect these existing cases to continue to play out unchanged while the lawyers continue to happily collect their fees," he said.

Black said the proliferation of software patents has led to an "unnecessary arms race."

"But it's an arms race that you almost have to participate in," he said. "It's also an arms race that inherently disadvantages new entrants, small dynamic companies.

"The most innovative new entrants wind up immediately facing a barrage of legal intimidation, lawsuits, threats," the CCIA president said.

Endpoint Technologies Associates' Kay said consideration should be given to doing away with software patents altogether.

"People patent any old thing and they repatent things that are already patented," he said. "Really we should be going 180 degrees in the other direction and saying 'How about no patents for software?'"


Related Links
Satellite-based Internet technologies

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

China's Alibaba chief silent on Yahoo stake
Hangzhou, China (AFP) Sept 10, 2011
The head of Chinese Internet giant Alibaba, Jack Ma, Saturday gave no hint of the future of Yahoo!'s stake in his firm but said he wasn't responsible for the recent ouster of its chief. Alibaba, China's top online retailer, is 43 percent-owned by the US Internet company. Yahoo!'s board of directors fired chief executive Carol Bartz just days ago and announced a "strategic review", amid s ... read more

United Launch Alliance Launches GRAIL Spacecrafts To Moon

NASA launches twin spacecraft to study Moon's core

Second bid to launch NASA's Moon-bound spacecraft

NASA to launch Moon-bound twin spacecraft

Orbiter Resumes Use of Camera

Sealed-in British scientist relies on plants to breathe

Microbe Risk When Rover Wheels Hit Martian Dirt

Finishing Work at Tinsdale 2

Space food, shuttle tiles for sale by NASA

Planetary Congress meeting in Moscow

US Congress sends Obama major patent overhaul

NASA Needs to Preserve Skilled Astronaut Corps In Post-Shuttle Era

Tiangong 1 might be launched in late September

Chang'e-2 moon orbiter travels around L2 in outer space

China State media says Tiangong 1 to launch in early Sept

Time Limits for Tiangong

NASA Sits Tight as Unmanned Space Station Considered

Russia sets space crew's return after crash

NASA mulls 'what-ifs' of unmanned space station

Wyle Selects Paragon Software For Disaster Recovery Solutions For ISS

European satellite in French Guiana launch

Arianespace to launch Amazonas-3 for Hispasat

Roscosmos to enhance control of Soyuz rocket engines' production

Russia beefs up Plesetsk space center funding

Invisible World Discovered

The diamond planet

Greenhouse Effect Could Extend Habitable Zone

A Planet Made of Diamond

Samsung files patent complaint against Apple in France

Two radiation generators mark major milestones in helping protect the US

Falling satellite could scatter debris

Aitech Appoints Vice President for Growing Space Business Sector

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement