Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .




RUSSIAN SPACE
Don't pass the buck, Roskosmos
by Natalia Antonova for RIA Novosti
Moscow (RIA Novosti) Jan 13, 2012


Head of Roskomos, Vladimir Popovkin.

The head of Roskomos, Vladimir Popovkin, has insinuated that the embarrassing failure of Phobos-Grunt (which I wrote about earlier) could be attributed to a shadowy plot of some kind. "I don't want to blame anyone, but there are powerful means of affecting [the performance] of spacecraft out there," Popovkin told Izvestia. "We cannot discount the possibility that they were used."

To back up this claim, Popovkin pointed out that there is something "inexplicable about the problems with our spacecraft when they're [on the other side of the planet and can't be monitored properly]."

Vague insinuations of sabotage are a dogwhistle for those who are more than eager to write off any such failure on the work of Russia's enemies abroad.

Unfortunately for Popovkin, any thinking person will immediately see his words for what they are - without a concrete theory as to how and why Phobos-Grunt may have been sabotaged, this looks to be a classic means of passing the buck.

Phobos-Grunt was not just a disappointment for Russia - it carried a Chinese Mars Orbiter and microorganisms that were supposed to be part of an experiment by the Planetary Society, which was aimed at testing how certain organisms survive in deep space (and whether or not they survive at all).

At a time like this, the need to point fingers is particularly high. People are coming off the winter holiday high, and everyone's in a bad mood already - without the lifeless Phobos-Grunt spinning uselessly in a low orbit, ready to crash down to Earth, Icarus-style.

Yet admitting a technical failure makes an agency look way, way better than hinting at the possibility of sabotage. The fact that Popovkin merely hinted is what makes it look particularly bad - a bolder claim would at least make Roskmos look as though it's willing to put its reputation on the line.

As such, this is just an attempt to divert attention away from the controversy surrounding the doomed spacecraft safely, a.k.a. eating your cake and having it too.

Popovkin did much better when he pointed out the good reputation of Russia's Soyuz rockets in the same interview - which have done a good job with missions to the International Space Station.

At a time like this, it's best to play up one's strengths and admit one's weaknesses - and unmanned Mars missions are certainly a kind of an Achilles heel for Russia's space program at this time, while the Soyuz rockets, as cosmonaut Andre Kuipers told my colleague Olaf Koens recently, are a reliable classic.

Popovkin's hints of sabotage also took away from another good point he made to Izvestia - and that is whether or not the constant presence of people in space is sustainable right now.

Considering both space pollution and the global economic crisis, his doubt on this is certainly something to reflect on at this time - no matter how much of a bummer it would be to see the glittering lights of the ISS extinguished for the time being.

Source: RIA Novosti

.


Related Links
-
Station and More at Roscosmos
S.P. Korolev RSC Energia
Russian Space News






Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle








RUSSIAN SPACE
Russia hints at foul play in its space failures
Moscow (AFP) Jan 10, 2012
The head of Russia's beleaguered space programme hinted on Tuesday that foreign powers may be behind the string of failures that struck his agency in the past year. Roskosmos chief Vladimir Popovkin told the Izvestia daily he could not understand why several launches went awry at precisely the moment the spacecraft were travelling through areas invisible to Russian radar. "It is unclear ... read more


RUSSIAN SPACE
Lunar orbiter spots moisture locations

'Mini moons' may surround Earth

Rare Moon mineral found in Australia

Ecliptic Shoots for Moon at End of a Record Year

RUSSIAN SPACE
Mars Express spots wrinkle ridges and grabens in Tempe Terra

Mars Science Lab Completes Biggest Maneuver On Route To Mars

Stranded Mars probe to crash into ocean Sunday: Russia

Russia was well aware of Phobos-Grunt mission risks

RUSSIAN SPACE
The gadgets which stood out at CES

Smart appliances set to transform the home

Boeing begins NASA solar electric propulsion study

Solid state Swiss Army Knife can save digital lives

RUSSIAN SPACE
China launches Ziyuan III satellite

Spying on Tiangong

China's space ambitions ally glory with pragmatism

Why The X-37B Is Not Spying On Tiangong

RUSSIAN SPACE
ISS Team Undertakes 'EPIC' Event

Photographing the International Space Station from Your Own Backyard

New crew arrives at international space station

NASA 'Smart SPHERES' Tested on ISS

RUSSIAN SPACE
Canaveral has busy 2012 launch schedule

China to launch Bolivian satellite in 2013: Chinese Ambassador

Ariane 5, Soyuz, Vega: Three world-changing launch vehicles

Satellites: Europe's Arianespace sets 13 launches for 2012

RUSSIAN SPACE
Scientists Discover a Saturn-like Ring System Eclipsing a Sun-like Star

Planets around stars are the rule rather than the exception

Milky Way teaming with 'billions' of planets: study

Kepler Mission Finds Three Smallest Exoplanets

RUSSIAN SPACE
Lens makers focus on smartphone cameras

CES gadgets bringing the "Matrix" to life

Apple suspends iPhone sales at China stores

ESA Coordinates International Satellite Reentry Campaign For Phobos-Grunt




The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement