Subscribe free to our newsletters via your
. 24/7 Space News .

New media world won't end need for journalists: study
by Staff Writers
Washington (AFP) Nov 28, 2012

Bloggers, "crowdsourcing" and computer-generated articles are making contributions to the news media, but they cannot replace professional journalists in digging up important news.

That is the message of a major study released this week by Columbia University's Tow Center for Digital Journalism, titled "Post-Industrial Journalism."

The authors of the report said technology has led to an explosion in the amount of information available, with economic shifts which are affecting journalism in both negative and positive ways.

But in certain kinds of reporting, professional journalists cannot be replaced by machines or crowdsourcing, the study said.

It is not journalism's best moment if much key work were taken over by amateurs, or done by machine, the study said.

"What is of great moment is reporting on important and true stories that can change society. The reporting on the Catholic Church's persistent harboring of child rapists, Enron's fraudulent accounting and the scandal over the Justice Department's Operation Fast and Furious are all such stories."

The role of the journalist "as truth-teller, sense-maker, explainer -- cannot be reduced to a replaceable input... we need a cadre of full-time workers who report the things someone somewhere doesn't want reported," the authors said.

But because of the changes to the media, the report said the advertising-supported model of newspaper and broadcast journalism may never be the same, and this means news "has to become cheaper to produce."

"There is no way to preserve or restore the shape of journalism as it has been practiced for the past 50 years," said authors C.W. Anderson, Emily Bell and Clay Shirky.

They said the changes have lead to "a reduction in the quality of news in the United States," and added: "We are convinced that journalism in this country will get worse before it gets better, and, in some places (principally midsize and small cities with no daily paper) it will get markedly worse."

The report argued that social media, blogs and "crowdsourcing" can have a positive influence by generating content not available in the past.

The authors note that the first reports on the raid killing Osama bin Laden came from a Pakistan IT consultant who tweeted what he witnessed, and that social media provided a more complete view of the Japan 2011 earthquake and tsunami than any individual journalist could provide.

They also conclude that tech startups like Palantir, Kaggle and Narrative Science which produce news stories from raw data through algorithms are also useful, and can free up professional journalists for other tasks.

The study said news reporting has always been "subsidized" in some manner, usually by advertising, and that a shift to online news with lower revenues has led to a search for a new model.

"The American public has never paid full freight for the news gathering done in our name. It has always been underwritten by sources other than the readers, listeners or viewers," the report said.

To make the economics work, the authors suggest flexibility: "Income can come from advertisers, sponsors, users, donors, patrons or philanthropies; cost reductions can come from partnerships, outsourcing, crowdsourcing or automation. There is no one answer."

One development in the media is the emergence of sites like the Huffington Post which maintain content from rival news organizations is "fair use," which can be taken in some form without payment.

"HuffPo management realized that fair use, as applied on the Web, meant that, in essence, everything is a wire service and that excerpting and commenting on unique content from The Washington Post or The New York Times was actually more valuable to readers than contracting with the AP or Thomson Reuters," the study said.

"The Huffington Post has often been criticized for this stance, but this is shooting the messenger -- what it did was to understand how existing law and new technology intersected."

The study concludes that because readers use a variety of sources, news organizations must therefore find a niche.

"There is a place for careful, detailed analysis... There is a place for impressionistic, long-form looks at the world far away from the daily confusion of breaking news. And so on," it said.

"Not many organizations, however can pursue more than a few of these modes effectively, and none that can do all of them for all subjects its audience cares about."


Related Links
Satellite-based Internet technologies

Comment on this article via your Facebook, Yahoo, AOL, Hotmail login.

Share this article via these popular social media networks DiggDigg RedditReddit GoogleGoogle

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Clash on Web radio royalties hits Congress
Washington (AFP) Nov 28, 2012
The clash over music royalties for Internet radio moved to Capitol Hill Wednesday, as lawmakers opened debate on a proposal to revamp the fee system. Pandora Media, the biggest US Internet radio firm, stepped up its push for reforms, claiming at a hearing that the multi-tiered system for royalties is stifling innovation. But backers of the music industry complained that writers and artis ... read more

China's Chang'e-3 to land on moon next year

Moon crater yields impact clues

Study: Moon basin formed by giant impact

NASA's LADEE Spacecraft Gets Final Science Instrument Installed

Regional Dust Storm Dissipating

One Year After Launch, Curiosity Rover Busy on Mars

Fostering Curiosity: Mars Express relays rocky images

Matijevic Hill Survey Complete And Rover Passes 22 Miles Of Driving!

Why Study Plants in Space?

Who's Killing the Space Program?

Fly me to the universe

UK Secures Billion Pound Package For Space Investment

Mr Xi in Space

China plans manned space launch in 2013: state media

China to launch manned spacecraft

Tiangong 1 Parked And Waiting As Shenzhou 10 Mission Prep Continues

NASA, Roscosmos Assign Veteran Crew to Yearlong Space Station Mission

Three ISS crew return to Earth in Russian capsule

Station Crew Off Duty After Undocking

Space station command changes

South Korean rocket launch suspended

EchoStar and Arianespace sign new satellite launch services contract

Soyuz ready for Friday launch of Pleiades 1B at Kourou

Sea Launch Postpones Satellite Launch Until Dec. 3

Low-mass planets make good neighbours for debris discs

Dust Grains Highlight the Path to Planet Formation

Magnesium oxide: From Earth to super-Earth

Rare image of Super-Jupiter sheds light on planet formation

NASA Technologists Test 'Game-Changing' Data-Processing Technology

UTC Aerospace Systems Selects Headwall Hyperspectral Imaging Sensor For SYERS-2 Program

Samsung launches new Internet-connected camera

20 workers injured as tornado hits Italy steel plant

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement